Tiverton
DEM Tiverton case at standstill
01:00 AM EDT on Monday, April 28, 2008
TIVERTON — While lawyers work on a potential settlement in a federal lawsuit brought by residents seeking remediation of contaminated soil on their properties, a parallel administrative case at the state Department of Environmental Management remains in limbo.
The administrative action crawled to a halt late last fall, as the DEM anticipated a pretrial ruling by U.S. District Senior Judge Ernest C. Torres in the residents’ federal case.
Those homeowners in the Bay Street neighborhood of North Tiverton have asked the court to order the Texas-based utility Southern Union to clean up toxic wastes in about 100 properties covering 50 acres.
In late January, Torres sent the DEM’s chief legal counsel a letter in which he said he wanted to ensure that the agency “is not under the mistaken impression that it is under any obligation to refrain from pursuing whatever course of action it deems appropriate to remediate the Tiverton site as expeditiously as possible.”
“On the contrary,” Torres told the DEM’s in-house lawyer, Patty Alison Fairweather, “I would encourage DEM to take whatever steps it considers necessary to effect prompt remediation.”
Through a spokeswoman, DEM Director W. Michael Sullivan declined any direct comment on Torres’ January letter, or the status of the DEM case in light of the potential court settlement, which was sealed by the judge last week.
Earlier this month, Sullivan confirmed that Fairweather has left the agency, saying the parting was a mutual decision.
Fairweather had been involved in several controversies during the last few years, including the hiring of a Washington law firm to buttress her own staff in the Tiverton case. The outside firm has billed the state a total of $1.2 million in fees that were not budgeted, although much of that money has been paid through available funds.
Torres placed his letter to Fairweather on the public record Jan. 24.
Nearly a week later, he rejected an argument by Southern Union that the residents could not obtain relief from their situation by appealing to the court because soil remediation fell under the exclusive purview of DEM.
The next day, Jan. 31, Torres invited DEM to participate in mediation that was hoped would resolve the contamination dispute.
The administrative proceedings were halted pending the outcome of the mediation which DEM hoped would also resolve its enforcement action against Southern Union.
The mediation was unsuccessful, but meanwhile, lawyers arrived at a conditional settlement last Tuesday in the resident’s case, the day before jury selection was to begin in the federal trail.
The stay in the DEM case expired April 19. The hearing officer, Kathleen Lanphear, has indicated she would entertain another 30-day extension in the stay, but as of Friday, such a request had not been made.
More Tiverton stories
Most viewed yesterday
Donaldson -- Brady's health will determine how far these Patriots go
After two preseason games, Patriots are far from being a super team
Inmate had sex with supervisor during work release, officials say
West Warwick, state of Rhode Island propose settlements in Station fire
Most active surveys
Are you considering switching to a cheaper alternative to heat your home?
Should the drinking age be lowered?
React to the latest Station fire settlement offer
Most e-mailed in the last 24 hours
Making the switch: Home heating oil versus natural gas
Despite soft market, pricey condos are selling / Video








