Boston Red Sox

Comments | Recommended

Bill Reynolds: A guy who hates the knuckleball tips his cap to Tim Wakefield

01:00 AM EDT on Thursday, July 16, 2009

Truth be told, I’ve never been much of a Tim Wakefield fan.

Not that it’s anything personal.

It’s the knuckleball.

Has there ever been more of a freaky pitch –– a fluttering, unpredictable affront to baseball purity –– than the knuckleball, this goofy pitch that no one knows where it’s going to end up, including the guy who throws it?

This is major-league baseball?

It sure doesn’t seem like it.

The knuckleball seems better suited to some kids’ playground game on some lumpy field in the dying twilight, a remnant of a childhood memory when no one can ever throw the ball over the plate and everyone stands around in the outfield hoping that someone, anyone, will finally hit the ball in their direction.

The essence of baseball is the confrontation between the pitcher and the batter, the ultimate test.

It’s not supposed to be about the vagaries of a pitch that floats up to the plate on a whim of its own, as if independent from the man who has thrown it, baseball’s mystery pitch.

And what is Tim Wakefield without the knuckleball?

Long retired, that’s for sure.

There was even the sense at the end of last year that he had used up his usefulness with the Red Sox. He was 42, seemed to spend too much time every year on the disabled list, and needed to have his own personal catcher.

Remember?

I certainly do. I even wrote it once, stuck in the middle of a larger column, suggesting that maybe it was time to bid Wakefield adieu, that maybe it wasn’t worth the effort anymore.

Well, here it is nine months later and here is Tim Wakefield on the All-Star team. Here it is nine months later and here is Tim Wakefield in what is arguably the season of his baseball life.

Good for him.

For I still don’t like the knuckleball, but I have come to admire Wakefield.

And maybe that’s because it’s like he’s been around here since the beginning of time, 1995 to be exact. He got here in April of that year, having just been released by the Pirates. He was first sent to Pawtucket, so rest assured he didn’t come to the Red Sox to the sound of trumpets blaring.

Then again, his entire professional career had been spent swimming against the current. The great story is about the time a scout told him as a young player that he would never get beyond Double A. He was an infielder then, and as the story goes, he began fooling around with the knuckleball, this exotic pitch that’s been around the game since the beginning of the time, or at least since the early days of the 20th century.

Pitchers who throw are often seen as belonging to some secret baseball cult, one with its own rules and secret handshake, men who have come to know that their careers belong to the unpredictability of a pitch that no one knows what it’s going to do, including them. Almost by definition they are seen as freaks, often misunderstood by managers, not appreciated by other players, often off in their own private Idaho.

So it began for Wakefield, the long journey that Tuesday night took him to his first All-Star Game in St. Louis, the symbolic highpoint of his long career in the game. He began throwing the knuckleball in Single-A in 1990, and two years later was called up by the Pirates in the middle of the season, striking out 10 Cardinals in his first game.

But it was never an easy road, not even then. Knuckleball pitchers are always suspect, usually either very good or very bad, sometimes in the same inning. By 1993 he was back down in Double-A, and spent much of the following year in Triple-A.

He found a home with the Red Sox, certainly, sometimes with success, sometimes with less than success, sometimes as a starter, sometimes in the bullpen.

The one constant?

He was always there.

Pitchers came and went, and came and went again. And still there was Wakefield. Managers came and went, the conga line from Kevin Kennedy to Terry Francona, and still there was Wakefield. Everything seemed to come and go, caught up in the revolving door that’s contemporary baseball, and still there is Wakefield.

There’s no question he’s had his ups and downs with the Sox, as if his career is often as up in the air and as uncertain as the knuckleball itself. He’s been in the rotation, and out of it, too. He’s had innumerable people through the years call talk shows and say the Sox would be better off without him, that he was too much of a one-trick pony.

He gave up the extra-inning home run to the Yankees’ Aaron Boone in the ALCS in 2003, the play that ended the Sox’ season, one of the most dramatic losses in Sox history. And the knock on him is always that you can’t count on him in the playoffs because you never really know what you’re going to get from him.

Still, he’s in his 15th summer now with the Red Sox, something no other player on the roster can say.

All this, and he’s off to the best start of his career at age 42.

Who would have ever believed it?

Not me, that’s for sure.

But here he is now in this season of what so far has been the best in his baseball life, 11-3, the best start in the game. Here he is now with stats that say he is one of the best pitchers in the long history of the Red Sox, third in all-time wins behind only Cy Young and Roger Clemens, second in all-time wins in Fenway Park behind only Clemens. Here he is with a career that no one ever could have envisioned.

Here is Tim Wakefield, the ultimate baseball survivor, one of the very best stories of this baseball summer.

Sometimes it’s good to be wrong.

breynold@projo.com

Advertisement

Reader Reaction