[an error occurred while processing this directive]
 

projoCars Test Drives

Saturn hybrid SUV is a thrifty compromise

01:00 AM EDT on Saturday, June 14, 2008

By Steven Cole Smith

The Orlando Sentinel

The 2008 Saturn Vue Green Line Hybrid, above, and instrumentation, left, is a “single mode” hybrid vehicle, meaning that the gas engine is always on when it is moving.


GM

Let’s get this out of the way first: Yes, the sensible, comparatively simple Saturn Vue Green Line is a hybrid, but it does not get the astronomical fuel economy that Toyota Prius drivers crow about.

But those of us who don’t much care for the Prius’ driving characteristics might be willing to sacrifice mileage for some of the Vue Green Line’s other attributes, such as interior room and luggage capacity. And the fact that the Green Line saves some gas — well, that’s gravy.

Actually, it saves quite a bit of gas, considering the relative absence of high-priced, high-tech hybrid components. The Vue Green Line is a partial hybrid, or “single mode,” as the manufacturers have taken to calling it, meaning that it can’t move under electrical power alone, as the Prius can. The smallish battery pack helps the 2.4-liter gasoline four-cylinder engine do its work, and it allows the engine to shut down under most circumstances at stoplights, but it does not replace the gas engine as a source of motivation.

That said, a “dual mode” Saturn Vue hybrid is due shortly, and while it will get better fuel economy, it will also be more complex and more expensive.

Until then, there’s not much wrong with an EPA-rated 25 miles per gallon city, 32 mpg highway, and 28 mpg overall, is there? Especially since our actual mileage was 28.6 mpg, and we were not particularly light on the Vue’s throttle.

The base gas-powered, four-cylinder Vue, by comparison, is rated at 19 mpg city, 26 mpg highway, and 22 mpg overall. That Vue starts at $21,875, so given the test Green Line’s out-the-door sticker of $24,795, and that includes a lot of equipment, going Green Line won’t cost you that much more green.

A substantial part of the Vue Green Line’s thrift comes not just from the hybrid powertrain, but other, smaller adjustments, such as the low-rolling-resistance tires (“hard,” in other words), and some aerodynamic tweaks, such as a special rear spoiler. There is nothing particularly sophisticated about the 2.4-liter gas engine, or its behind-the-times four-speed automatic transmission, but it all works well enough together.

On the road, the Vue Green Line rides and handles about as you’d expect, though there was a lot of tire and wind noise. Inside, instruments and controls are simple and straightforward. Cloth front seats are moderately comfortable, but rear seats are hard and upright and lack legroom. Interior trim is a festival of plastic, some of it not fitted together particularly well at the Saturn assembly plant in Mexico.

There’s a lot of luggage room in the rear, and even more under the flip-up floor, revealing a lot of black Styrofoam cubbyholes that are certainly light, but seem down-market.

Outside, we can’t fault the styling: The Vue, in any configuration, is one of the best-looking small SUVs at any price.

And speaking of price, really, it isn’t bad: Besides the gas-saving hybrid aspect, you get stability control, antilock disc brakes, traction control, side and side-curtain air bags, keyless entry, OnStar, XM satellite radio and full power-operated features. Saturn also has an extended eight-year, 100,000-mile hybrid-component warranty, and there’s little doubt the under-stressed hybrid batteries should last that long, and then some.

All for less than $25,000: A good value, especially at current gas prices.

ProjoCars’ archive of test drives is like visiting a single showroom that features all current makes and models: projocars.com

Advertisement

More top stories

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Most Viewed Yesterday

Most active surveys

Updated Tues 11.10.09

Most e-mailed in the last 24 hours