Contributors
Tom Plate: An inspiring Harvard-to-Dartmouth move
01:00 AM EDT on Wednesday, March 11, 2009
BEVERLY HILLS
IT ISN’T EASY these days to find silver linings in the economic clouds. But if history tells us anything, there must be a few in there somewhere. So perhaps a little imagination is in order to skirt the current oppressive mood.
Imagine that we earthlings began to take the long view of life, like the Chinese philosophers, or the composers of symphonies, or the writers of great novels. Nothing of any great value or even significance takes place in a short period; it is only by taking the long view that meaning is found and achievement is reached.
These thoughts arose in the context of a surprising development in higher education in the United States. Dartmouth College, one of the world’s finest small liberal-arts schools, announced a new president.
Its choice is notable on a number of accounts.
One is that the appointee is abandoning his position at Harvard University as a famous medical school official and researcher. Most people would imagine that the average hot shot would go from a small college like Dartmouth to a giant like Harvard — not the other way around. The second point of note is that the recent appointee is Asian-American, and becomes the first of his ethnicity to head an Ivy League institution.
This has to be major news across the Pacific. No one values higher education more than Asia and Asians, and I would bet that more Koreans, say, have heard of Dartmouth than people in, for example, Tennessee. I have met some Koreans, in fact, who’d be tempted to commit a high crime to get their child into an American school as good as Dartmouth — and I note this with admiration!
Dr. Jim Yong Kim, a physician and an anthropologist who received his M.D. and Ph.D. from Harvard, was born in South Korea but immigrated to the United States at an early age. He received his bachelor’s degree from Brown University, another world-class university. And then he went onto gigantic Harvard, where he rose to chairman of the Department of Global and Social Health at Harvard Medical School.
Despite this stratospheric résumé, there was always something odd about Dr. Kim. The main thing: He not only loved to teach students, but he actually preferred to teach mainly undergraduate students. This is most unusual among top academics.
For many high-flying professors, teaching undergrads is often viewed as beneath one’s station: as a chore, if not a hardship — an impediment to “real scholarship and learning.”
And it is not only de-prioritized in the culture of the professor, but often in the university administrations, which reward and promote faculty almost entirely on the basis of scholarly papers published, awards received and eminent recognitions earned — and not on quality of teaching.
At large universities, public and private, the college undergraduate student is at the bottom of the totem pole. I’ve known professors to practically scamper in the other direction when they see one coming, keep their office hours to the absolute minimum and maneuver like Donald Trump to keep from having to teach an undergrad course.
At small liberal-arts colleges, by contrast, the undergrads are the kings and queens. At my own undergraduate alma mater, Amherst College, in leafy (and oft-frozen) western Massachusetts, faculty would not be hired and certainly would not be promoted unless teaching ability was very high on the list of prominent skills. Teaching ability — and, especially, avidity — is primo at prestigious small schools across America, such as Williams, Swarthmore, Kenyon and Occidental. At Santa Monica College, here in Southern California (perhaps the best two-year junior college in America, many say), President Chui L. Tsang personally — personally! — interviews each teaching candidate recommended to be hired by the faculty in an effort to identify and reject poorly motivated teachers. This is great.
Technical and practical education will always have its rightful place — and in a terrible economy will seem more urgent than ever. But the smart cultures and decision-makers will always understand, even in the worst of times, the value of expanding minds and horizons.
Authorities in Singapore, sometimes viewed by outsiders as one big cheerless science and math lab, have been talking to Pomona College, the superb, lively liberal-arts college east of Los Angeles, about helping it set up a Pomona analogue in their own country. How very smart.
Dr. Kim spoke of the huge opportunity at Dartmouth to “train an army of leaders to engage with the problems of the world, who will believe the possibilities are limitless, that there’s nothing they can’t do.”
There’s something about his dramatic decision to leave Harvard — and about Dartmouth’s decision to grab him — that’s inspiring.
Folks of the world: Think long-term about America — not just about today’s Dow Jones average — and you come away with a much sunnier, much more hopeful feeling.
Tom Plate, a UCLA professor for 14 years, is a frequent contributor, a syndicated columnist and veteran American journalist now working on a book on Asia.
| Teachers protest in Central Falls | |
| Rhode Island Emergency Management Agency prepares for storm | |
| 'We are in trouble': At Warwick's T.F. Green airport, travelers' flights canceled |
We want to hear from you
More editorials
Most Viewed Yesterday
Baseball Notes: Lowrie working very hard to get back on radar screen
Unregulated sober houses are a vital resource
Most active surveys
Is Drew Brees the best quarterback in the NFL?
Your turn: If the election were held today, who would get your vote for governor?
Reader Reaction







Follow projo on Twitter
Follow projo on Facebook

You must be logged in to contribute. Log in | Register Now!
You are logged in as screenname | Log Out
You are logged in, but do not have a "screen" name. Create a Screen Name