Editorial columnists
McCain no anti-abortion fanatic
01:00 AM EDT on Thursday, June 12, 2008
HILLARY CLINTON’S blessing notwithstanding, many of the New York senator’s supporters will resist the handover to Barack Obama. The sexism that permeated the recent campaign still rankles, and John McCain is far from the standard-issue Republican they instinctively vote against.
A big sticking point for wavering Democrats will be McCain’s position on reproductive rights. Clinton’s backers are overwhelmingly pro-choice, and they’ll want to know this: Would McCain stock the Supreme Court with foes of Roe v. Wade? The 1973 decision guarantees a right to abortion.
The answer is unclear but probably “no.” While McCain has positioned himself as “pro-life” during this campaign, his statements over the years show considerable latitude on the issue.
George W. Bush turned those statements against him in the 2000 race for the GOP nomination. The National Right to Life Committee ran ads denouncing McCain — one reason he lost the important South Carolina primary to Bush.
Addressing conservative South Carolinians last year, McCain said that Roe should be overturned. Primary politics or a change of mind? The former is my guess — and also that in his current pursuit of Hillary Democrats we may see a softening of that position.
Whatever McCain really thinks, the chances that he would submerge his presidency in the maelstrom of abortion politics seem slim. Partisan battles over court nominees aren’t his thing either.
McCain played a central role in the Gang of 14 — the 7 Democratic and 7 Republican senators who joined hands to find common ground on court appointments. For his efforts at compromise, McCain took a pummeling from the right wing. Note that Obama, the self-styled foe of division, declined to join the bipartisan group.
And if a President McCain did put forth a controversial candidate, the Democratic majority in the Senate — sure to grow after the upcoming election — would put a quick end to the idea. That’s why McCain would probably choose a cipher as some of his Republican predecessors have done. Reagan gave us Sandra Day O’Connor, and George H.W. Bush picked David Souter. Both justices were essentially friendly to Roe.
Obama is no doubt pro-choice, but on the abortion issue he hasn’t been exactly a profile in courage. As an Illinois state senator he famously voted “present” on anti-choice legislation. Voting “present” is a tactic used to express disapproval without actually taking a stand.
In February, Bonnie Grabenhofer, the president of Illinois National Organization for Women (and Clinton supporter), wrote: “We made it clear at the time that we disagreed with the strategy. . . . Voting present doesn’t provide a platform from which to show leadership and say with conviction that we support a woman’s right to choose and these bills are unacceptable.”
For someone representing Obama’s very liberal Chicago district, there was zero danger in voting “no” on an anti-abortion bill. He almost certainly voted “present” as political cover should he run for higher office and need to appeal to a wider base of voters. And run for higher office he soon did. Nowadays, most abortion fights center on regulations. The movement to ban the procedure outright suffered a disastrous blow in 2006, when the conservative voters of South Dakota threw out a state law that would have virtually barred all abortions.
Curious Democrats will have many questions about the Arizona senator’s positions on taxes, health care and war. But they need not obsess on what a McCain presidency would do to Roe. That is one war McCain is unlikely to wage.
Froma Harrop is a member of The Journal’s editorial board and a syndicated columnist.
| Cigars are smoking | |
| Bristol float retells the story of George Mendonsa of Middletown, known as the Kissing Sailor | |
| Weather brings down tree limb on house in Cranston |
We want to hear from you
How to submit a letter to the editor
More editorial columnists
Civilizing offenders requires community relationships
Most Viewed Yesterday
Senate commission to study marijuana decriminalization
Jury awards Roger Williams hospital patient $3.9 million
Supporters of state name change poised to woo voters’ support
Most active surveys
Why do you think Sarah Palin is prematurely stepping down as Alaska's governor?
How is this weather affecting you?
Should marijuana be decriminalized and taxed?
If the election for governor was held today, who would you vote for?
Most e-mailed in the last 24 hours
Reader Reaction









You must be logged in to contribute. Log in | Register Now!
You are logged in as screenname | Log Out
You are logged in, but do not have a "screen" name. Create a Screen Name