Rhode Island news
CVS Trial: P.R. chief prepared 'talking points,' government apparently wraps up
02:33 PM EDT on Friday, May 23, 2008
Todd Andrews, left, Brown University vice president and former CVS manager of corporate communications, answers questions from prosecutor Stephen G. Dambruch, center, in court today. Judge Mary Lisi presides.
PROVIDENCE -- CVS's former communications director testified today that when he learned John A. Celona was a paid consultant of the giant Woonsocket-based drugstore chain, he devised a title and prepared "talking points" to explain Celona's duties in case a reporter ever called to ask about it.
Todd Andrews, now vice president of alumni relations at Brown University, testified in federal court that defendant Carlos Ortiz told him about Celona early in 2001, about one year after the then-North Providence senator went on the CVS payroll as a $1,000-a-month consultant.
Andrews said that Ortiz raised the issue during a "gripe session" about his boss, John R. "Jack" Kramer.
Today's exhibits
Exhibit 109: Read Todd Andrews "talking points" describing what Celona did for CVS, prepared in case a reporter called
Exhibit 394: Read Carlos Ortiz's Rhode Island state grand jury testimony, which was introduced by the prosecution today
Ortiz and Kramer are accused of 23 counts of bribery, conspiracy and mail fraud for allegedly hiring Celona as a consultant from 2000 to 2003 to do the company's bidding. The defense, however, says Celona did legitimate community outreach, promoting CVS and its charitable endeavors to senior citizens.
Later in the day, the prosecution appeared to have finished presenting its case, and Chief U.S. District Judge Mary Lisi sent jurors home early, telling them to return Tuesday, after the holiday weekend.
Andrews testified that Ortiz told him "that Mr. Celona was acting as a P.R. consultant for CVS, that he was going to senior centers and talking to seniors about services they were getting from CVS," Andrews said of Ortiz.
Ortiz also told Andrews that Celona helped prepare Kramer for appearances on Celona's cable access television show.
"He told me that Celona had an Ethics Commission ruling that made that work permissable," Andrews said.
Ortiz also said, according to Andrews, that Celona was providing reports "accounting for what he was doing for the company."
At the end of the conversation, Andrews said, Ortiz asked him: "please don't tell anyone."
Andrews testified that he went back to his office and developed written talking points, later approved by Ortiz, that described Celona's duties. Andrews said that he also gave Celona a title -- community outreach specialist.
Earlier today, a former CVS vice president, Jim Smith, testified that when he took over the CVS government affairs department in spring 2003, he conducted a budget review and asked Ortiz about Celona's consulting agreement.
"I asked Carlos, 'Are we getting any value for that?' and he said no. So I recommended that we terminate him," Smith said.
Celona was terminated later that summer.
After hearing today from Smith and Andrews, jurors heard from Susan DelMonico, a lawyer who works in the Woonsocket-based CVS’s regulatory compliance division.
DelMonico testified that starting in the late 1990s, she spent a lot of time touting CVS in visits to senior citizens centers around Rhode Island as the company’s manager of community relations. She also said that she met former Celona at political fundraisers she attended with co-defendants Kramer and Ortiz.
But the prosecution didn’t get to another point it apparently wanted to highlight –– a conversation that DelMonico said she had with Kramer about Celona.
A defense lawyer for Ortiz objected to the prosecution’s question. That led to a sidebar conference between the lawyers and the judge, and after that, there were no further questions from the government and none from the defense.
After DelMonico finished, Judge Lisi turned to prosecutors at 11:30 this morning and said that it appeared the government had no more witnesses for the day. She then sent the jury home about 90 minutes early for the long holiday weekend.
Judge Lisi told the jurors to return to court next Tuesday at 9 a.m., at which point the government is expected to rest and the defense will have its turn to argue motions seeking dismissal of the charges and, barring that, to present its case.
| Bristol 4th: Learning about America for the nation of Tajiskistan | |
| Covering the General Assembly: The 2009 Session | |
| Cigars are smoking |
More top stories
Still ancient, still horrible, parade still draws a crowd
Bristol puts its best foot forward in 224th Fourth of July parade
Most Viewed Yesterday
Senate commission to study marijuana decriminalization
Jury awards Roger Williams hospital patient $3.9 million
Supporters of state name change poised to woo voters’ support
Most active surveys
Why do you think Sarah Palin is prematurely stepping down as Alaska's governor?
How is this weather affecting you?
Most e-mailed in the last 24 hours
Reader Reaction









You must be logged in to contribute. Log in | Register Now!
You are logged in as screenname | Log Out
You are logged in, but do not have a "screen" name. Create a Screen Name