Rhode Island news
Dismissal requested of DCYF lawsuit
01:00 AM EDT on Wednesday, October 3, 2007
The state yesterday asked the federal court to dismiss a class-action lawsuit filed in June by the state child advocate, who claimed the Department of Children, Youth and Families had tragically failed to protect many children in its custody.
In the motion for dismissal, prepared in part by Attorney General Patrick C. Lynch, Lynch and other state lawyers questioned the appropriateness of the remedy sought by Child Advocate Jametta O. Alston — namely asking the federal court to take control of DCYF.
“Rhode Island has a Family Court with both the ability and expertise to review any and all DCYF cases ...,” Lynch said in a statement. “Indeed, Rhode Island’s child advocate is one of these very resources. She has always had complete access to DCYF’s records and to the Family Court.”
Lynch said Alston could easily seek the Family Court’s help if she deemed intervention is needed.
“The fact that she didn’t, and has never done so for any of the children whom she claims are not getting the attention they need, does not stop her from doing so in the future,” Lynch said.
Alston filed the class-action suit in June and portrayed the entire child-welfare system as overburdened and mismanaged.
“It’s beyond broken,” she said at the time. “It’s demolished. It doesn’t work.”
Her suit claimed children in foster care were being molested and beaten and, in one high-profile case, killed. Her suit claimed state caseworkers labor under “excessive caseloads,” too many children were being placed in institutions and group homes, and that children were being reunited with parents who had abused them.
Alston, who was appointed by Governor Carcieri — one of the parties now asking that her suit be dismissed — claimed in the class-action suit that the state has known about systemic problems in DCYF for years and failed to meet some basic obligations to the children in its care.
“This, to me, is a last resort,” Alston said at the time she filed the class-action suit.
Her suits used pseudonyms for 10 children in foster care who claim they’ve been damaged by the state system, including two brothers who were allegedly returned over and over again to parents who abused them.
In the state’s motion for dismissal, filed on behalf of Carcieri and the directors of the Department of Health and Human Services, lawyers termed the definition used in Alston’s suit to describe the proposed class of victims as “ambiguous.”
They claim Alston defined the parties as “all children who are or will be in the legal custody” of DCYF who may have been abused or neglected. The motion for dismissal claims that definition is too broad to allow a judge to ascertain membership of a class of alleged victims.
Further, the motion for dismissal claims, Alston didn’t include “foster” children in her own definition of those she was representing.
Because the parties of the class-action suit aren’t more specifically defined, the lawyers for the state argue the class-action suit should be dropped.
| H1N1 and Pets: Felines, Ferrets and Flu | |
| Barrington's affordable housing puts opportunities within reach for mother, daughter | |
| Police seize large quantity of marijuana in Woonsocket |
More top stories
Trial opens in death of actor’s brother
Bishop again attacks Kennedy over abortion stand in health-care reform
Most Viewed Yesterday
The hunt for Stephen Saccoccia’s hidden assets
Vehicle fatalities climb in R.I.
Suspect shot during struggle with undercover officer
Patriots journal: Belichick says Moss is smartest receiver he’s seen
Most active surveys
Are the Yankees on the brink of another dynasty?
Is it a bad thing or a good thing that prostitution is legal in Rhode Island, indoors?
What's your favorite breakfast/lunch place?
React to Carcieri's veto of R.I.'s first saltwater fishing license
Has your behavior changed in light of the swine flu outbreak?
Most e-mailed in the last 24 hours
Reader Reaction









You must be logged in to contribute. Log in | Register Now!
You are logged in as screenname | Log Out
You are logged in, but do not have a "screen" name. Create a Screen Name