Rhode Island news
Group imagines — and works on — a nursing home designed with the input of patients
01:00 AM EST on Friday, November 14, 2008

Kevin McKay, the director of the Tockwotton Home in Providence, meets Bernice “Bunny” Bronson, a resident there who participated in the study of how to design nursing homes in the future.
The Providence Journal / Bob Breidenbach
Imagine living in a place where someone dictates when you can eat, when you have to wake up, and when –– if ever –– you can go outside. Imagine that the only place you can entertain guests is in your bedroom. Imagine that taking a shower has become a dreaded ordeal.
A diverse group of experts recently spent hundreds of hours not just imagining, but observing and documenting just such a place: a nursing home.
Its objective was to understand the experience through the eyes of the residents. And its ultimate goal is to find –– and test –– ways to make it better.
This unusual Rhode Island-based project is called the Nursing Home of the Future. The future in question belongs to the baby boomers, who number 78 million nationwide and aren’t getting any younger. They are also unlikely to tolerate the restrictions and indignities of today’s nursing-home environment.
“There is pitiful little focus on something we know is coming,” says Joseph F. Coughlin, director of the AgeLab at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, speaking of the demographic tidal wave. The first boomers will turn 65 in 2011; already, there are more nursing homes than McDonald’s.
The AgeLab is among an array of partners –– including people from the Rhode Island School of Design, Brown University, Quality Partners of Rhode Island and some private companies –– who were pulled together by the Business Innovation Factory, or BIF.
BIF is a four-year-old nonprofit organization, launched with support from the state Economic Development Corporation, which envisions and tests new ideas, such as a better design for hospital trauma bays or a new communications system for port security. BIF shelled out $125,000 for the first phase of the Nursing Home of the Future, which ended last month.
Dr. Richard Besdine, director of Brown University’s Center for Gerontology and Health Care Research and an adviser to the project, helped the group think through its most important goal: to change nursing homes so they are no longer the last place anyone wants to be.
“The thing that’s so ghastly,” Besdine said, “is that you lose control of your life.” You live on a schedule set by the institution. You live in a small room. “If you can walk in the other person’s shoes, you’re halfway there,” he said.
The first part of the project was an effort to enter the lives of elderly people at the Tockwotton Home, a 30-bed assisted-living facility and 42-bed nursing home in Providence’s Fox Point. Tockwotton is a not-for-profit nursing home with a good reputation –– Bes- dine called it a “gem” –– which is planning to open a new building in East Providence in 2010. The new Tockwotton will include a “laboratory area” for testing the ideas that emerge from the Nursing Home of the Future project.
“A lot of people are studying in particular silos –– they’re studying one particular aspect,” says Mickey Ackerman, director of BIF’s Experience Lab and the former head of the industrial design department at RISD. Ackerman says that people tend to separately examine medical, social, psychological and business issues. In contrast, he said, the Nursing Home of the Future looks at everything as an interrelated whole. “We are focused on the user –– the person who’s living this kind of life,” he said.
The BIF researchers spent many hours at Tockwotton, volunteering, chatting, photographing, filming –– and befriending the residents.
For example, Matt Cottam, the head of the Web design firm Tellart who worked on the nursing home project, and David Watson Sobel, another participant, decided to offer a blood pressure screening as a way to interact with people at Tockwotton. But when the residents showed up, they said they didn’t want their blood pressure taken. Instead, they relished the opportunity to speak with outsiders. They started asking questions about blood vessels and how the heart works. Cottam and Sobel happen to be emergency medical technicians. Cottam located a dummy used to teach CPR, and the blood pressure screening morphed into a CPR class.
“Before I started this project,” Cottam told a BIF conference recently, “I naïvely thought nursing homes were places you put broken people for maintenance care until they die. … But it’s not true at all. These people have lived for an entire century, some of them. They’re at, in some ways, the richest point in their lives. They have the most to offer. They have the most interesting conversations. And they’re continuing to live. This is another chapter in their lives.”
But many aspects of their lives have changed. With physical limitations, eating “turns into a chore, not a joy,” Cottam said. Getting dressed can involve major mental and physical stress. Moving from one activity to another is a challenge. And even at a nursing home that offers an array of activities, there are often not enough new things to fill one’s day. Cottam compared it to sitting in the airport for three-quarters of the day.
Back at the office, the researchers created a wall-size map depicting the life experience of the nursing home residents. They identified several areas to work on. A top issue is personal care and hygiene. It’s humiliating to need assistance using the toilet or taking a shower, and the process can be cumbersome. Residents avoided showers as long as they possibly could. One of the BIF observers got a sense of why: she sat in the awkward shower seat and imagined being frail and naked, washed by someone else.
Can better clothing design eliminate the need for toileting help? Can monitoring technology allow more privacy? Can bathrooms be made safer and easier to use? BIF is working with corporations, such as a Swedish company that makes personal-care products, to address some of these issues. But its principals are quick to add that they’re not just looking for new gadgets.
“It’s really easy to focus on little things,” says Ackerman. “That’s not going to solve the big problems of aging.”
As a nonprofit organization, BIF can place clever technological solutions within a bigger picture, says Melissa Withers, BIF spokeswoman, “so it’s not just about that new showerhead.”
“The Nursing Home of the Future is more about reassessing and redesigning the systems we call nursing homes,” says MIT’s Coughlin. “That includes the relationship with families, how we pay for it, what can [residents] do productively in nursing homes. … What we’re lacking is innovation. We have more structured programs and connectivity for people who are in prison than for our parents.”
Now, the BIF researchers hope to work with their corporate partners on a few of the most promising ideas to emerge from their days at Tockwotton, and ready them for testing at the new Tockwotton in 2010.
“The people at Tockwotton taught us so much,” Cottam said. “They taught us that opportunity is everywhere.”
To learn more about the project, go to http://www.businessinnovationfactory.com/nhf/ R.I. nursing home facts Nursing homes: 92 Patients: Approx. 8,400* R.I. residents 65 & older: 149,775 R.I. residents 70 & older: 117,391 R.I. residents 75 & older: 82,292 * Based on 90 percent occupancy of 9,300 licensed nursing home beds Sources: Rhode Island Department of Health, 2006 Census Bureau estimates
| Animal Behaviorist, Christine Johnson | |
| Sweetbriar provides opportunities for Tara Dodson and her daughter Avery | |
| Police seize large quantity of marijuana in Woonsocket |
More top stories
Position on gays shatters union of 2 Methodist churches
Most Viewed Yesterday
Patriots journal: Porter says refs have different rules for Brady
Governor vetoes R.I. saltwater fishing license
Narragansett sachem: ‘Outsiders’ no more after Obama meeting
Most active surveys
React to Carcieri's veto of R.I.'s first saltwater fishing license
What's your favorite breakfast/lunch place?
Are the Yankees on the brink of another dynasty?
Will you get vaccinated against swine flu this year?
Will you allow your children to be vaccinated against swine flu? Why or why not?
Most e-mailed in the last 24 hours
Reader Reaction









You must be logged in to contribute. Log in | Register Now!
You are logged in as screenname | Log Out
You are logged in, but do not have a "screen" name. Create a Screen Name