The Price of Miracles: Families, modern medicine and premature birth | projo.com | The Providence Journal The Price of Miracles: Families, modern medicine and premature births

March 1, 2009

Why the high rate of preterm births among African-Americans?
By FELICE J. FREYER
Providence Journal medical writer

Even the stress of racism is being considered a factor in the high number of African-American women who give birth prematurely.

Call it the Miracle of Dane County.

Or maybe the Mystery of Dane County.

Last year, health officials in the Wisconsin county noticed that infant mortality among blacks had dropped by a stunning 70 percent in a five-year period. In the rest of Wisconsin, the black infant mortality rate remained the highest in the nation. But Dane County, which encompasses the capital city of Madison, completely closed the gap between white and black, a gap that appears in virtually every community in the United States.

Wisconsin health officials cheered the news -- but couldn't explain how it happened.

A closer look at the data found that infant mortality among blacks dropped because they had many fewer extremely premature babies, and those who were born prematurely were recovering better.

The county health department is studying what happened and expects to have an answer in three years. The findings will be of interest around the country because the high rate of preterm births among blacks remains one of the great puzzles of the prematurity epidemic. Nationwide, 18.1 percent of black babies are born prematurely, compared with 11.5 percent of whites.

Pregnant women who are poorly educated and have little income or social support are more likely to deliver preterm babies. African-Americans are disproportionately represented among the poor, so socioeconomic factors have long been blamed. But then, studies showed that even high-income, highly educated black women were having more preemies. In fact, a college-educated black woman is still more likely to have a premature baby than a white woman who didn't graduate from high school.

Some believe that the racial disparity in preterm births may be determined by genes. Certainly genetics are known to play a role in premature births, which can run in families. But genes cannot explain it all. Otherwise, African-born immigrants to the United States would also have high preterm birth rates. Instead, at least according to one study, African immigrants had preterm birth rates similar to those of white Americans.

"Race is really not a biological concept. It's a social concept," says Dr. Diane Ashton, deputy medical director of the March of Dimes, which since 2003 has focused on understanding and fighting premature births and which has financed research and social services targeted at African-Americans.

A newly developing theory, Ashton says, points a finger at racism. This theory holds that day-by-day encounters with discrimination could promote premature birth, by inducing chronic stress. A 2004 study found a connection between an African-American woman's lifetime exposure to racism and her likelihood of delivering a very low birthweight child.

It could be as simple as "someone deciding as you walk into a store -- they don't see your degree -- but you are a potential thief," says Dr. Dannie Ritchie, director of the Transcultural Community Health Initiative of Brown University, and an African-American family doctor who has studied the effect of inequality on health.

"It's vigilance. It's being hypervigilant, always concerned that something is lurking to discredit you," Ritchie said.

One of the early observations from Dane County seems to back up that idea. The researchers talked to focus groups of African-American women of two generations, and were struck by the difference in their feelings. "The weight of discrimination and racism seemed to be fairly heavy in the older group of women," said Dr. Thomas Schlenker, Dane County's public health director. Younger women, in contrast, "seem to feel very positive about how they're accepted into the community."

The high quality of life in the county, and quality of health care, could also play a role.

"What I hope [the research] shows is that living in an inclusive and supportive community is good for you," Schlenker says. "And if we can demonstrate how that actually makes a difference in how babies survive or not … we will really have something to share with other cities in Wisconsin and elsewhere."

ffreyer@projo.com

Read other stories in this chapter:
Group preterm care mixes camaraderie, education to help moms go the distance
Homeless, black and poor: From statistic to success

Untitled Document

Untitled Document


 

RELATED STORIES
Homeless, black and poor: From statistic to success
Homeless, black and poor: From statistic to success
Read the story

Group preterm care mixes camaraderie, education to help moms go the distance
Group preterm care mixes camaraderie, education to help moms go the distance
Especially for African-Americans, the camaraderie and education found in such group prenatal care programs as Centering Pregnancy has helped prevent premature births.
Read the story


VIDEO
Yvonne Freeman
Yvonne Freeman video
Homeless when her fourth child was born at 24 plus weeks, Yvonne Freeman went on to become a nurse. "I was very interested in nursing because of the care that Xavier received. So right away, I wanted to go to nursing school. And I did."
Watch the video


Untitled Document

GRAPHIC
Every day matters
Development outside of the womb
Track the week-to-week development of the heart, lungs, brain and digestive system in the womb, the impact of premature birth on these organs, and on a preemie's survival.
Explore the graphic

QUIZ
Are you at risk?
Are You at Risk? an interactive quiz

What's known -- and what isn't -- about the factors that contribute to premature birth.
Take the quiz

GRAPHIC
Intensive care
for the tiniest babies

Narrated illustration: Intensive care for the tiniest babies
A narrated illustration of the high-tech equipment that helps premature babies breathe, keeps them warm and shields them from infection in the neonatal intensive care unit.
Explore the graphic

Share your story

An early birth has a long aftermath. In ways obvious or subtle, shocking or imperceptible, preemies are different –– perhaps for a lifetime. Do you know someone who was born early? How is he or she doing?

Parents of preemies: What do you think of plans for the new NICU?

Do you have a teenager who was born prematurely? Have you found that adolescence poses new problems?

Parents who have faced uncertainty with their preemies: What advice was helpful to you, and what advice would you offer others in similar circumstances?

Tell us about your experience with premature birth


CHART

On the rise in RI
Preterm births in Rhode Island have steadily increased since 1990, but the growth has been chiefly among late preterm births