| By Sheila
Lennon
'Bottom-up' journalism from the pros
Fair and balanced, too!
August 29, 2003 6:40 p.m. -- (Last
week's weblog)
This is the strangest collection of items in my 17 months of blogging.
Maybe Mars is to blame, but my money's on Pluto. Have a great Labor Day
weekend. Back here Tuesday.
Accused
Web Attacker Under House Arrest: AP reports,
An 18-year old from a Minneapolis suburb accused of spreading a damaging
Internet infection weeks ago was arrested Friday and later released
under restrictions set by a federal judge.
U.S. Magistrate Judge Susan Richard Nelson told Jeffrey Lee Parson
not to access the Internet or any other network connection and placed
him on electronic monitoring.
Parson, known online as "teekid," told the judge he understood
the charges against him. He didn't enter a plea during his initial court
appearance. His next hearing is scheduled for Sept. 17 in Seattle, where
the case was being investigated.
... Parson, a 6-foot-4, 320-pound high school senior from Hopkins,
spoke only in response to questions from the judge.
He wore a T-shirt that read "Big Daddy" on the front and
"Big and Bad" with a grizzly bear on the back. He sported
metal stud under his lip and his hair was dyed blond on top and shaved
close around the sides and back.
He looked straight ahead, never turning toward his parents seated in
the back row of the courtroom. His mother sighed heavily and wiped tears
away from her face before the hearing. Neither she nor Parson's father
would comment afterward.
That's
Parson, 18, at right, in his high school yearbook photo. All AP moved
this afternoon was a dark photo of a car window in which a man's shirtfront
could be seen; Parson was holding a piece of paper between his head and
photographers.
Google's
cache of Parson's site, t33kid.com, shows the message,
p2p.teekid.c
my little p2p worm spreads via kazaa and imesh, downloads a file from
web. No biggie.
(Although there's a download link, I figured I'd spare myself a visit
from the law by not clicking on it.)
An
earlier AP story begins, "Neighbors of 18-year-old Jeffrey Lee
Parson say the high school student in federal custody for launching a
worldwide computer virus was a loner who drove too fast and didn't appear
to have many friends and idolized Bill Gates."
Yet another AP story (Friends
say Parson knew he was in trouble) about the man with few friends
begins,
Jeffrey Parson blabbed to his friends about a month ago that he was
working on modifying a computer virus, a friend said Friday....
It also seems odd that Parson would idolize Microsoft chairman Bill
Gates, considering the virus contained the message, "billy gates
why do you make this possible? Stop making money and fix your software!"
(Mama said there'd be days like this.)
Link
to this item | Comment
Your tax dollars at work?The Washington Post
reports (Halliburton's
Deals Greater Than Thought)
Halliburton, the company formerly headed by Vice President Cheney,
has won contracts worth more than $1.7 billion under Operation Iraqi
Freedom and stands to make hundreds of millions more dollars under a
no-bid contract awarded by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, according
to newly available documents. ...
Possibly related: Doc
Searls quotes at length from The
Promise and the Threat, a post on Baghdad
Burning (billed as a "Girl Blog from Iraq" -- and just added
to the blogroll at right). Here's a snippet:
Listen to this little anecdote. One of my cousins works in a prominent
engineering company in Baghdad- we’ll call the company H. This
company is well-known for designing and building bridges all over Iraq.
My cousin, a structural engineer, is a bridge freak. He spends hours
talking about pillars and trusses and steel structures to anyone who’ll
listen.
As May was drawing to a close, his manager told him that someone from
the CPA wanted the company to estimate the building costs of replacing
the New Diyala Bridge on the South East end of Baghdad. He got his team
together, they went out and assessed the damage, decided it wasn’t
too extensive, but it would be costly. They did the necessary tests
and analyses (mumblings about soil composition and water depth, expansion
joints and girders) and came up with a number they tentatively put forward-
$300,000. This included new plans and designs, raw materials (quite
cheap in Iraq), labor, contractors, travel expenses, etc.
Let’s pretend my cousin is a dolt. Let’s pretend he hasn’t
been working with bridges for over 17 years. Let’s pretend he
didn’t work on replacing at least 20 of the 133 bridges damaged
during the first Gulf War. Let’s pretend he’s wrong and
the cost of rebuilding this bridge is four times the number they estimated
-- let’s pretend it will actually cost $1,200,000. Let’s
just use our imagination.
A week later, the New Diyala Bridge contract was given to an American
company. This particular company estimated the cost of rebuilding the
bridge would be around -- brace yourselves -- $50,000,000 !!
I hope the investigative journalists in Baghdad check this out.
And Doc also points to the original Baghdad blogger Salam Pax's post
relating
that his family's home was searched by American troops:
...They have been “informed” that there are daily meetings
the last five days, Sudanese people come into our house at 9am and stay
till 3pm, we are a probable Ansar cell. My father is totally baffled,
my brother gets it. These are not Sudanese men they are from Basra the
“informer” is stupid enough to forget that there is a sizeable
population in Basra who are of African origin. And it is not meetings
these 2 (yes only two) guys have here, they are carpenters and they
were repairing my mom’s kitchen. Way. To. Go.
Link
to this item | Comment
"Things
fall apart; the centre cannot hold" -- William Blake: Onetime
cult figure Robert
Anton Wilson, perhaps best known back when for The
Illuminatus Trilogy, Quantum
Psychology: How Brain Software Programs You and Your World and
Cosmic Trigger is running as the unofficial write-in candidate
for governor of California as the head
of the Guns and Dope party:
Position Paper #1
After refusing many pleas to run for governor,
I have reconsidered and now enter the race
as an unofficial write-in candidate. After
all, why shd I remain the ONLY nut in California
who ain't running?
Link
to this item | Comment
Hall
of Technical Documentation Weirdness: You've tried to assemble
something that came with diagrams -- wordless instructions -- or you've
puzzled over a garment tag that tried to convey its content or care only
in pictures. Now there's a site that honors these maddeningly inscrutable
messages.
Link
to this item | Comment
Behind
the "time traveler" spam: You've gotten it --
messages with the subject "Time
Traveler Needs Dimensional Warp Generator." It asks that a DWG
unit be left at latitude N 42.49430, longitude W 071.14275 -- Majority
Lane, in Woburn, Mass. Here's the sad story behind it, at Wired:
A trail of Internet clues has fingered Robert "Robby" Todino
as the source of the time-travel messages. In a telephone interview
last week, the 22-year-old Woburn, Massachusetts, resident admitted
that he has sent nearly 100 million of the bizarre messages since November
2001.
"It almost feels worthless now because the people who are monitoring
my every move always seem to win. But it's the only form of communication
I have right now," Todino said.
His father, Robert Todino Sr., worries that malicious users have preyed
on Robby's "psychological problems" and bilked him out of
money.
"What bothers me is that some people are trying to sell him equipment
and take advantage of him," said Todino Sr. "He's invested
a lot of money into it and has been hurt by it."
But Robby insists that he is "perfectly mentally stable,"
and that the time-travel technology he seeks is out there somewhere.
Perhaps related:
A Watch Powered by Snake Oil, also at Wired:
Like a deflector shield protecting the Starship Enterprise from its
enemies, a new watch promises to shield the body from "electronic
pollution" from cell phones and other gadgets.
The Philip Stein Teslar watch contains a chip that works with the battery
and coil to create a frequency that neutralizes the electromagnetic
fields emanating from devices like cell phones, computers and radios,
according to the company.
Link
to this item | Comment
Bush's telemarketers are in India? The Inquirer
(U.K.) reports, (US
Republican Party outsources fund raising to India: Whole world's gone
batty - official):
THE REPUBLICAN PARTY is using call centres in Gurgaon and Noida in
India to raise funds for itself and for its chieftain, George W. Bush.
Young people at the call centres are helping robots to phone American
citizens to enlist their support and money for the political party,
with plans to extend the scheme if they whip up enough donations.
...We do hope and trust here at the INQUIRER that the irony of underpaid
people in Harayana helping robots to call possibly out of work Americans
because of a widespread policy of corporate outsourcing is not lost
on our readers.
WorldNetDaily offers
more details.
Link
to this item | Comment
Ashcroft
Taking Fire From GOP Stalwarts: More
Wish to Curb Anti-Terrorism Powers
BOISE, Idaho -- Even here, in a bedrock Republican state in the heart
of the conservative Mountain West, a lot of people think Attorney General
John D. Ashcroft has gone too far.
One of this state's most prominent politicians, Rep. C.L. "Butch"
Otter (R), is leading an effort in Congress to curtail the centerpiece
of Ashcroft's anti-terrorism strategy, the USA Patriot Act. Sen. Larry
E. Craig (R-Idaho), who used to croon alongside Ashcroft in a senatorial
quartet, said this month that Congress may have to consider scaling
back parts of the law. And in a state with an all-GOP congressional
delegation, several city councils and the legislature are considering
resolutions condemning Ashcroft's tactics in the war on terrorism.
"Ashcroft wants more power," said state Rep. Charles Eberle
(R-Post Falls), who has drafted a resolution critical of the Patriot
Act. "What a lot of us in Idaho are saying is, 'Let's not get rid
of the checks and balances.' . . . People out here in the West are used
to taking care of themselves. We don't like the government intruding
on our constitutional rights."
Link
to this item | Comment
August 28, 2003 7:10 p.m.
Ordinary folks' photographs of Mars: When
I first put together Aug. 22's How
to photograph Mars, I had hoped to follow by inviting readers to upload
their photos of the planet to a projo.com slideshow. I abandoned the notion
after I realized how underwhelming a collection of black backgrounds with
a bright dot might look.
Bless 'em, some people found ways to make
fine pictures. Here are three sites worth visiting to see interesting
photos that defied the obstacles.
•
Shy Globe of War: I should have realized when Shelley
(Burningbird)
Powers linked
to my Mars tips and mentioned her mom had given her a telescope
that her interest was more than academic. Sure enough, she took the
challenge -- got a big blurry red Mars:
I have a good camera, a Nikon 995, but not a beauty like a D100 or
even, in my dreams, a D1X. I have a good telescope, a Meade ETX70,
but not a powerhouse like the 14" Schmidt-Cassegrain. Added to
the mix, I don't have an attachment that will allow me to take photos
through the special port on the telescope and I have to use the eye
piece. This is my way of saying that my photos of Mars are properly
orange, helped a bit by the haze and the 800 ISO camera setting, and
I guess we'll need to be content with that.
I'm more than impressed that she actually did it.
• Mike Lee (curiousLee):
Mars
looms large and bright
...Just a few hundred feet into Indiana, we made a right turn into
tomato patch so I could set up for a time exposure. The best image
out of many attempts is offered here. In this fisheye lens view, I
composed the rising Mars over our PT Cruiser, and used an LED flashlight
to lightpaint the foreground during a 30 second exposure. ...
The round photo, with a necklaces of Marses hopping through time and
the sky, looks astonishingly like a Christmas tree ornament.
•
Mars Rising Behind Elephant Rock is NASA'S Astronomy
Picture of the Day today. Wally
Pacholka is the photographer, and Elephant Rock is in Nevada's in
the Valley of Fire State Park.
Did you photograph Mars, or have you seen a site with such photos? Please
let me know. I'd
like to see as many as are out there.
Link
to this item | Comment
Serendipity tosses up a gem: I found Nora
Murphy's blog while searching for Mars photos. No Mars photos there,
but instead a post headlined Rules
for hiring that includes "Eleven Tips on Getting More Efficiency
Out of Women Employees" from the July 1943 issue of Transportation
Magazine. "1943 Job Standards and Rules for Hiring Women" was
written for male supervisors of women in the work force during World War
II:
1. Pick young married women. They usually have more of a sense of responsibility
than their unmarried sisters, they're less likely to be flirtatious,
they need the work or they wouldn't be doing it, they still have the
pep and interest to work hard and to deal with the public efficiently.
2. When you have to use older women, try to get ones who have worked
outside the home at some time in their lives. Older women who have never
contacted the public have a hard time adapting themselves and are inclined
to be cantankerous and fussy. It's always well to impress upon older
women the importance of friendliness and courtesy.
3. General experience indicates that "husky" girls - those
who are just a little on the heavy side - are more even tempered and
efficient than their underweight sisters. ...
Go read the rest of 'em. They're a hoot.
Link
to this item | Comment
The best Japanese restaurant in Rhode Island?
I disagree with Journal restaurant reviewer Meridith
Ford's choice today of Haruki (reg.req.) for that distinction.
My favorite is Ran Zan, at 1084 Hope St. in Providence, just before the
Pawtucket line -- a mom-and-pop restaurant.
It's small, with about 10 tables, a six-seat sushi bar and a tatami room
in the back you have to know is there (there are no signs). The decor
is Zen-simple -- white walls, a few black and white prints, the only color
a short noren curtain above the sushi bar, indigo panels with batik-look
white bamboo, tiny red bows holding the panels together.
And the food is superb, fresh and interesting. The sashimi (sushi without
the rice, for purists) is always fresh-tasting. The sesame salad dressing
does wonders for lettuce. The gyoza -- steamed dumplings -- are addictive.
Sushi lovers will find a wide assortment, and the beautiful dragon roll
is a good choice. The lavender-colored Mochi ice cream -- it's made from
bean paste, but don't let that stop you -- with a slightly elastic texture
is a treat for Western tastebuds. It also comes in a green tea variety.
Tempura, teriyaki, udon noodles and much more are offered, as are saki
and beer.
We find ourselves there at least once a week, and have never had a bad
meal. Check it out.
(The quiet owners have no I idea who I am or where I work, and will probably
never see this.)
Link
to this item | Comment
How
Everyday Things are Made: Fascinating videos at Stanford University's
Alliance for Innovative Manufacturing for anyone who wonders what makes
things tick. A high-speed connection is required to watch them.
If you've ever wondered how things are made - products like candy,
cars, airplanes, or bottles - or if you've been interested in manufacturing
processes, like forging, casting, or injection molding, then you've
come to the right place.
AIM has developed an introductory website showing how various items
are made. It covers over 40 different products and manufacturing processes,
and includes almost 4 hours of manufacturing video. It is targeted towards
non-engineers and engineers alike. Think of it as your own private online
factory tour, or a virtual factory tour, if you wish.
Link
to this item | Comment
A New Battleground
In Web Privacy War: Ads That Can Snoop: Software Programs Track
Where Users Go On Net, Then Target Them With Pop-Ups
August 27, 2003 6:26 p.m. -- (Last
week's weblog)
MIT
Everyware: Every lecture, every handout, every quiz. All online. For
free.
...No institution of higher learning had ever proposed anything as
revolutionary, or as daunting. MIT would make everything, from video
lectures and class notes to tests and course outlines, available to
any joker with a browser. The academic world was shocked by MIT's audacity
- and skeptical of the experiment. At a time when most enterprises were
racing to profit from the Internet and universities were peddling every
conceivable variant of distance learning, here was the pinnacle of technology
and science education ready to give it away. Not the degrees, which
now cost about $41,000 a year, but the content. No registration required.
"It's a profoundly simple idea that was not intuitive," recalls
Anne Margulies, the former Harvard assistant provost and executive director
of information systems who was hired to be OpenCourseWare's executive
director. "At the time, the world was clamping down on information,
limiting it to those who could pay for it." Soon foundation money
was gushing in to support the initiative. MIT earned the distinction
as the only university forward-thinking enough to open-source itself.
To test the concept, the university posted 50 courses last year.
In September, as students arrive on the Cambridge campus for the start
of school, MIT
will officially launch OpenCourseWare with 500 courses...
If you've ever wished you'd studied architecture,
programming
(they've put the
whole introductory textbook online), genetics,
here's your chance.
But wait, there's more: The description of Media, Education, and the
Marketplace begins, "Lectures,
presented in streaming video format, feature a variety of educators
and visionaries addressing the course themes."
Link
to this item | Comment
Hubble
Makes Best Mars Globe Photos Ever:
Related: Mars
Trip Not on Political Radar
Link
to this item | Comment
Prints
the Chaff is a great blog by Tom Mangan, copy editor/page designer
on the features desk at the San Jose Mercury News. (Although today he's
fantasizing about a job opening in Cambodia.) Great wry voice.
Here's a sample:
Now this is great news:
AP
chief vows to transform news service. A couple highlights:
"We are transforming the AP from a wire service, which we've
been for 150 years ... to an interactive database and news network that
connects us, and not just connects us technically, but more importantly
connects our common business and journalistic goals."
Translation: more work for overworked Associated Press staffers, which
means more work for the rest of us cleaning up their copy. Now get this:
He said the news service is made up of "the greatest journalists
you'll ever meet." But the AP must make those journalists more
productive because, in an era of declining newspaper circulation and
hard economic times, "it's tough to imagine there will be more
slots" opening to expand the AP staff, he said.
Oh, wait, no new bodies to do these new duties. Oh, sure, they're going
to work smarter. (Because, you know, they've been so damn stupid all
these years).
respond by e-mail
| posted by tom mangan at 7:39 AM | perma-link
Link
to this item | Comment
More garden blogs: Kathleen Purdy of Cold
Climate Gardening emailed,
"Every so often I do get a visit from your site, so I thought I'd
reward you with some more garden blogs. They vary in quality and frequency
of posting, and some just teeter on the edge of actually being a blog.
But anyone who enjoys reading about what's going on in other peoples'
gardens will enjoy reading them all."
Thank you! Here they are:
http://www.welchwrite.com/agn/blog/
http://bashasgarden.blogspot.com/
http://clearwaterlandscapes.com/news/index.php
http://familyrobinson.blogspot.com/
http://home.att.net/~larvalbugbio/gardenindex.html
(Click on the link "chronological order" for a blog-like
journal)
http://gardendjinn.typepad.com/garden/
One of my favorites
http://www.stingykids.net/garden/
http://www.karinsbeautifulsite.com/garden.html
http://tectorum.com/
http://www.gardengal.net/page42.html
This is a page of links to personal garden websites. Most of them
probably don't have blogs or journals, but I haven't checked them all
out yet myself.
Link
to this item | Comment
More email: Jack Peters writes in response
to last week's 'Rho
Dyelinnahs' try to mind the r's:
As a former resident of the beautiful city of Central Falls, I read
in the Yankee Magazine that the letter "r" is added when the
first word ends in a vowel and the second word starts with a vowel.
Ex: manila envelope would sound like (maniller envelope), Visa account
would be spoken as (Viser account). That's the best explanation I've
heard . Sincerely, sjp
And, Steve, blogging at Absit
Invidia, responds to Lifting
the veil on gender apartheid, a National
Post story which notes that the hajib -- the head and face covering
worn by Muslim women -- has no religious significance but is rather a
recent invention. Steve headlines his item, France
to Muslim women: "Get that towel off your head!"
Link
to this item | Comment
Man
builds his own town:
FRUITLAND - Bub Hyder's town was almost complete, but something was
missing.
"I had built me a marshal's office and a jail, but I checked with
the feds and they said, `Bub, you can't put somebody in jail without
trying them in a court of law first,'" Hyder said. "So I built
a courthouse. I had kind of put the cart before the horse."
Puncheon Camp Creek Farm, the town Hyder has built on his 700-acre
farm in this apple-growing area of Henderson County, boasts a general
store, schoolhouse, church, hotel, filling station, livery stable, doctor's
office, a post office, a bank, a marshal's office and a jail. And the
combination courthouse/town hall/firehouse - modeled on the Hendersonville
City Hall, complete with granite steps - should be finished by Sept.
1.
Yes, you're just supposed to know where Fruitland, Henderson County and
Hendersonville are, since you're reading The Citizen-Times.
I looked at the bottom of the page and saw the word Asheville. I think
we're in North Carolina. Thanks to Liz
Donovan for the link.
Link
to this item | Comment
Thursday is Towel
Amnesty Day at Holiday Inns: "About the towels, we forgive
you."
Unlike libraries that offer amnesty if you return their books, they don't
seem to want their towels back. They do ask that you tell them the story
of how you came to have it.
I think you just packed it. How else would you get one?
Link to this item | Comment
GOP
= Goldwater's Old Party? W. James Antle III at Tech Central (Slogan:
Where free markets meet technology) succinctly examines a trend that's
been obvious here on the Web for quite a while:
The political coalition that has comprised the American right for half
a century is showing signs of breaking up as conservatives and libertarians
go their separate ways. While conservatives seem to be making peace
with government growth, libertarians are increasingly forging a separate
identity outside the right that often includes strategic alliances with
the left.
The writer and frequent TCS contributor Ronald Bailey has written in
an article
posted on the libertarian Reason magazine's website about joining the
ACLU, an old nemesis of the right. And TCS contributor Radley Balko
has stated on
his blog (this
link is to the item in which the following quote appears) that
"the right now poses a greater threat to freedom than the left."
In the September/October issue of Liberty magazine, editor R.W. Bradford
called for a libertarian-conservative divorce.
Link
to this item | Comment
Cell
transplant restores vision: BBC reports, "A blind man can
see again after being given a stem cell transplant."
This story's ending may not be all that happy for the patient, though.
He now knows how dangerous the world is:
...But Mr May was not fully comfortable with his newly gained sight.
Before the operation he had been a keen skier, using verbal directions
as a guide.
But after he recovered his sight, he was frightened he would crash
into something.
Over two years, he has learnt to use shading patterns on the snow to
estimate the shape of the slope.
Mr May is also nervous of crossing the road, where he was confident
of doing so while blind.
Link
to this item | Comment
Fox
drops lawsuit over Franken book (CNN); Salon
excerpts some of the book; Franken
crows. (The last two Salon links trade a free day pass for a few moments
with your eyeballs -- you have to watch an ad.)
Judge
Stops Deployment of Navy Sonar (Washington Post)
Siding
with the powerless: Ideas from 60 years in journalism by
Walter Cronkite, longtime CBS anchor; now retired, he has emerged to write
a syndicated column.
August 26, 2003 6:15 p.m.
Looking for How to photograph Mars? It's
here now. And here's one more link, to Sky
Photography.
When freshmen were photographed nude: We spent
the weekend in a cottage on Kennebunk Pond in Lyman, Maine. No TV, no phone,
no Web. Just loons, a thousand-piece jigsaw puzzle, a rowboat and a book,
a gift from a colleague: Ron Rosenbaum's anthology of his literary-journalism
pieces, The
Secret Parts of Fortune: Three Decades of Intense Investigations and Edgy
Enthusiasms. If you've only read Rosenbaum's recent New
York Observer columns on the Web, you may be surprised by how well
reported and vastly entertaining these gems are. I'll return to this,
but the very first piece I read was The Great Ivy League Nude Posture
Photo Scandal: In Which a Cunning Pseudoscientist Catches the Elite with
Its Pants Down, which is actually
reproduced here without a byline.
It originally appeared in the New York Times magazine in January 1995.
Here's the meat of it.
One fall afternoon in the mid-60's, shortly after I arrived in New
Haven to begin my freshman year at Yale, I was summoned to that sooty
Gothic shrine to muscular virtue known as Payne Whitney Gym. I reported
to a windowless room on an upper floor, where men dressed in crisp white
garments instructed me to remove all of my clothes. And then -- and
this is the part I still have trouble believing -- they attached metal
pins to my spine. There was no actual piercing of skin, only of dignity,
as four-inch metal pins were affixed with adhesive to my vertebrae at
regular intervals from my neck down. I was positioned against a wall;
a floodlight illuminated my pin-spiked profile and a camera captured
it.
It didn't occur to me to object: I'd been told that this "posture
photo" was a routine feature of freshman orientation week. Those
whose pins described a too violent or erratic postural curve were required
to attend remedial posture classes.
The procedure did seem strange. But I soon learned that it was a long-established
custom at most Ivy League and Seven Sisters schools. George Bush, George
Pataki, Brandon Tartikoff and Bob Woodward were required to do it at
Yale. At Vassar, Meryl Streep; at Mount Holyoke, Wendy Wasserstein;
at Wellesley, Hillary Rodham and Diane Sawyer. All of them -- whole
generations of the cultural elite -- were asked to pose. But however
much the colleges tried to make this bizarre procedure seem routine,
its undeniable strangeness engendered a scurrilous strain of folklore.
Not only Hillary and Diane, but also former Secretary of State Madeleine
Albright (Wellesley '59), who included a mention of the posture pictures
in her June commencement address at Washington University in St. Louis:
I attended a women's college, Wellesley, where we were all expected
to become young ladies. When we enrolled, we each had to pose for what
they called a posture picture to see whether we had, and I quote "an
understanding of good body alignment and the ability to stand well."
The thing is, we were not allowed to wear any clothing above the waist.
They actually graded the pictures, and if we flunked, they made us do
exercises. We always wondered what happened to the pictures, until a
few years ago. They were discovered in a vault — at Yale.
Not so, says Wilma Slaight, Wellesley's archivist. I called her today
to ask, "Where's my posture picture today?" (I was not a member
of "the elite," but I tested well, and slid into Wellesley as
a National Merit Scholar.)
"Wellesley did not keep them," Slaight said, "and Wellesley
did not allow them to be taken for external purposes." They were
a tradition of freshman orientation from 1926 to 1969, she noted, but
they really were about posture as it related to health and the ability
to perform physical education activities. In later years, she emphasized,
they were destroyed within a year of their creation.
The truly bizarre part of this saga is the use to which some of these
photos were put -- but apparently not those from Wellesley. Rosenbaum
writes,
...George Hersey, a respected art history professor at Yale, wrote
a letter to The Times that ran under the headline "A Secret Lies
Hidden in Vassar and Yale Nude 'Posture Photos.' " Sounding an
ominous note, Hersey declared that the photos "had nothing to do
with posture . . . that is only what we were told."
Hersey went on to say that the pictures were actually made for anthropological
research: "The reigning school of the time, presided over by E.
A. Hooton of Harvard and W. H. Sheldon" -- who directed an institute
for physique studies at Columbia University -- "held that a person's
body, measured and analyzed, could tell much about intelligence, temperament,
moral worth and probable future achievement. The inspiration came from
the founder of social Darwinism, Francis Galton, who proposed such a
photo archive for the British population."
And then Hersey evoked the specter of the Third Reich:
"The Nazis compiled similar archives analyzing the photos for
racial as well as characterological content (as did Hooton). . . . The
Nazis often used American high school yearbook photographs for this
purpose. . . . The American investigators planned an archive that could
correlate each freshman's bodily configura) and physiognomy with later
life history. That the photos had no value as pornography is a tribute
to their resolutely scientific nature."
A truly breathtaking missive. What Hersey seemed to be saying was that
entire generations of America's ruling class had been unwitting guinea
pigs in a vast eugenic experiment run by scientists with a master-race
hidden agenda.
At the Smithsonian, Rosenbaum found "20,000 photographs of men --
9,000 from Yale -- and 7,000 of women." Here's an overview of the
Sheldon collection at the Smithsonian.
Slaight faxed me an article from the Spring 1995 Wellesley alumnae magazine,
written to address the furor Rosenbaum's piece had stirred up. Pointedly,
one of the Q & A sections addresses posterity:
Are there any Wellesley posture pictures at the Smithsonian?
Officials at the Smithsonian have assured Wellesley in writing that
they can find no evidence of any photos of the College's undergraduates
in the collection.
Did Wellesley cooperate with William H. Sheldon or his colleagues?
What the Smithsonian officials did find in the collection was a 1950
letter from a Wellesley faculty member declining the Sheldon request
that Wellesley collaborate in the research.
I was barely 17 when I stripped for my posture picture, and I remember
the embarrassing episode vividly. I stood as straight as I could, fervently
hoping I'd pass so I wouldn't have to take a remedial posture class. I
also remember wearing underwear, which the alumnae magazine confirms:
"In the 1950s, the methodology was changed to a more 'subjective'
assessment and that was the point at which students were permitted to
wear underwear for the photographs."
Slaight says there are a few posture pictures in the archives, used in
the '30s in articles on the methods of measuring posture for physical
education teachers. There are no names attached, but Slaight does not
recall if the faces were obscured.
(Photographer Peter Marshall, in Science,
Nudes & Faces at about.com, reports, "From around the 1880s,
Harvard University had apparently made 'posture photographs' of its students
for medical reasons, using the results to screen students who needed treatment
for their posture (although this was largely totally unnecessary), and
in the 1920s this was developed at Wellesley, who sent a training film
about it to other colleges, and the practice became more popular.")
The alumnae magazine reprinted a 1941 article, "On Beautiful Carriage,"
written by the department chairman for her instructors. It is bizarrely
quaint.
Fortunately, phys ed at Wellesley in the late '60s was a succession of
sports in six-week chunks. After swimming, fencing and skiing (on campus
hills), I settled into my true calling: cox on an eight-woman crew shell.
It was low-energy, and depended more on my sense of rhythm than my muscles.
Being able to land the expensive shell without crashing it into the dock
was highly valued, and my posture was never mentioned again.
I saw the photograph of me with the pins down my spine -- I remember
a vertical line drawn on the photograph which my spine sometimes approached;
I passed, but barely. I don't know if I saw the photo as part of a conference
about my posture or if I got my own copy. Slaight thinks there was only
one copy, and that I saw it only briefly. (Rumors abounded, of course,
that Harvard men got hold of them all.)
Digitas, an undergraduate online journal at Harvard, addressed the posture
pictures in 1995 as well. This practice was not limited to Wellesley.
The short report, headlined The
Naked and the Nude, begins,
It is hilarious to imagine: the young George Bush, a first-year at
Yale, summoned mysteriously to a dingy, windowless room on the fourth
floor of Paine-Whitney Gymnasium. After waiting in line outside, Bush
enters the room, skinny and awkward; somewhat nervously, he follows
orders from two middle-aged men in shirtsleeves. He undresses at their
request. One of the men attaches metal spikes to his spine at regular
intervals and positions him in profile to a camera on one end of the
room.
Thanks, Ron Rosenbaum, for dredging up these memories. It's inconceivable,
from a 2003 perspective, that nude photographs would be as routine a part
of freshman week as getting books and a beanie.
Also bizarre: One of my new friends, a woman from Chattanooga, was far
more worried about the "speech tests" than about stripping for
the camera -- she was afraid these Yankees would force her lose her Southern
accent.
Link
to this item | Comment
Tomorrow, we'll get back to the news on the Web, and some of the email
that's arrived. For today, a couple of important links from J.D.
Lasica:
• A New York Times editorial today dissects the unpatriotic
USA Patriot Act.
• Group wants search engines freed from policing copyrights:
San Jose Business Journal via MSNBC:
Advocates for freedom of expression on the Internet issued a call
this week to change a federal law that requires search engines to remove
search results suspected of infringing on someone's copyright.
The federal Digital Millennium Copyright Act, the law that lets record
companies go after music fans for sharing copyrighted songs online that
they haven't paid for, also holds search engine companies liable for
other copyright violations. If a Web page violates a copyright, a search
engine can be forced to remove that page from its list of search results.
...
• "BBC opening its archives to public: This is pretty
interesting, and goes against the trend of subscriptions, walled-off
archives and for-pay services: The BBC plans to open its full content
archives -- television and radio, not just online -- to the public for
free. PaidContent.org has the item here,
as well as the
full text of the speech Sunday by BBC director general Greg Dyke,
who said, "I believe that we are about to move into a second phase
of the digital revolution, a phase which will be more about public than
private value; about free, not pay services; about inclusivity, not
exclusion."
Steve
Outing at E-Media tidbits adds, "Speaking of the BBC and free
content, here's another statement from a Beeb executive that's sure to
be controversial. Ashley Highfield, director of new media and technology,
told The Independent that news organizations seeking to charge for
news should "give up and move on"; only niche content can work
under a pay model, and the BBC does not operate in those areas. "
Subterranean Homepage News
by Sheila Lennon
features & interactive producer of projo.com |