• Home
  • :
  • :
  • Member Center
  • :
  • Make This Your Home Page




Business

Search Legal Notices

Airport salaries soar above most other state agencies

01:00 AM EDT on Sunday, July 20, 2008

By PAUL EDWARD PARKER

Journal Staff Writer

The airport is where the money is, at least as far as paychecks at quasi-public state agencies in Rhode Island are concerned.

A Providence Journal review of payroll records from 10 quasi-public state agencies found that employees at the Rhode Island Airport Corporation had the highest average paychecks in 2007, as well as having 4 of the 10 highest paid employees and 42 of the 100 highest paid.

Airport employees also land a fair share of overtime dollars, although those who drive a bus or work at the state’s Central Landfill rake in more.

Generally speaking, quasi-public state agencies are formed by the state but have at least partially separate legal identities, such as the ability to borrow money independently or to be sued separately from the state. The quasi-public agencies often look more like businesses than departments of state government. In Rhode Island, they do things such as run airports, operate transit buses and help first-time house buyers get mortgages.

Under state law, employees of the quasi-public agencies are public employees, and certain information from their personnel files is part of the public record. That includes their names, job titles and earnings information.

The Journal’s examination of the payrolls of quasi-public agencies follows earlier looks at state, municipal and public school employees. Some quasi-public agencies — including the state colleges and the public television station — process their payrolls through the state Department of Administration. The 10 agencies that are the subject of today’s review handle their own payrolls.

The highest paid at those 10 agencies last year was Mark P. Brewer, president and chief executive officer of the airport corporation. His $243,798 paycheck made him one of the highest paid of all state employees.

To make a direct comparison, the Journal also looked at 2006 earnings, because those were available for all state, municipal and school employees, as well as workers at the quasi-public agencies.

In that year, Brewer was paid $254,318. That trailed only James E. Baron, the men’s basketball coach at URI, who grossed $301,324. The highest paid public school employee that year was Donnie W. Evans, the former Providence schools superintendent, who grossed $190,742. Among municipal employees, the top earner was Michael J. Day, deputy assistant fire chief in Providence, although a substantial portion of his $186,541 in earnings was severance pay after he died on the job.

In 2007, the airport claimed the top three spots among employees of quasi-public agencies.

After Brewer, second-place went to Peter Frazier, the corporation’s lawyer. Frazier, whose pay totaled $192,536, also filled in as president after Brewer left to head the Manchester-Boston Regional Airport in New Hampshire. As a result, Brewer did not collect a full year’s salary.

Third was Brian Schattle, senior vice president and chief financial officer, who grossed $177,200.

A fourth airport employee, spokeswoman Patricia A. Goldstein, was the 10th-highest paid, grossing $141,654.

“The salaries may seem high, but that’s the reality of recruiting in the aviation field,” said Kevin A. Dillon, current airport corporation president. “You necessarily have to go and try to recruit folks away from other airports.”

He said a study completed last month showed Rhode Island airport salaries to be within the range of similar airports.

The biggest user of overtime last year, in terms of the percentage of total payroll, was the Rhode Island Resource Recovery Corporation, which runs the state’s dump. The corporation averaged overtime that was 22 percent of each worker’s total pay last year.

That use of overtime was a strategic decision, according to Michael O’Connell, the agency’s executive director.

The state requires the dump to operate 10 1/2 hours a day on weekdays, plus 6 1/2 hours on Saturdays. Instead of creating 40-hour-a-week schedules that cover all those hours, the corporation just has employees put in overtime.

“Rather than hire a bunch of extra people and pay them a benefit package, which you never recover, it makes more sense to pay overtime,” said O’Connell. “Economically, it always pays to run overtime than to hire more people.”

But, he said, the use of overtime is a high-wire act.

“Zero overtime — zero means you have too many people,” O’Connell said. “Too much and you’re wearing them out.”

Although Resource Recovery doles out the most overtime as a percentage of payroll, the biggest bucks come from the Rhode Island Public Transit Authority, which employs the overtime king.

Last year, RIPTA paid more than $5.6 million in overtime, with most of that going to the people who drive transit buses and the vans that transport people with disabilities.

More than half that overtime was planned, accord to Mark R. Therrien, a RIPTA assistant general manager. “In our industry, scheduled overtime is a strategic call,” he said. Part of that strategy is scheduling for a work day that has to be longer than eight hours to accommodate the schedules of RIPTA’s biggest customers, commuters who get rides before and after their own eight-hour work days.

Tops last year among all overtime earners at the quasi-public agencies was bus driver William A. Blair, who added $49,044 in overtime to his base pay of $48,013. With other earnings, his pay for the year totaled $98,342.

“Bill Blair never leaves the place practically,” said Therrien. “He’s the most senior driver at RIPTA, and he works any overtime he can.” Schedules and overtime are driven by seniority, and, Therrien said, Blair arranges his regular work schedule to be available at the times that have the most unplanned overtime, usually the result of someone calling in sick.

The airport was the third-biggest user of overtime, with about 10 percent of its payroll going to overtime payments.

“It’s something that any manager wants to shrink down as much as possible,” said airport president Dillon.

He said three factors beyond his control cause overtime situations.

One is snow removal. “We don’t have the option of saying we’re just going to close down” and wait out a storm, he said.

Another is maintaining adequate numbers of security personnel at times they weren’t expected to be needed. “When you have delayed flights, I have to hold people over,” he said.

The third is the airport fire department. Airport certification requires staffing levels to be maintained, even when workers call in sick or are absent for other reasons.

Besides resembling businesses in what they do, the quasi-public agencies were similar in how employees are paid.

In many state agencies, the top earner is a long-time rank-and-file employee, who has a high base salary because of longevity and high overtime earnings because seniority is often a factor in selecting employees for extra shifts.

But at 8 of the 10 quasi-publics looked at by The Journal, the head of the agency was the top earner. At the other two, the top earner was a high-ranking deputy.

Besides the Airport Corporation, Resource Recovery and RIPTA, the other quasi-publics looked at by The Journal were:

•The Rhode Island Convention Center Authority, which runs the convention center and civic center arena in Providence;

•The Rhode Island Economic Development Corporation, which helps attract businesses and keep them here;

•The Rhode Island Health and Educational Building Corporation, which helps schools, hospitals and similar agencies secure financing for building projects;

•Rhode Island Housing, the mortgage and housing agency;

•The Narragansett Bay Commission, which runs the sewer systems and treatment facilities that serve all or part of 10 communities in the Providence area;

•The Rhode Island Student Loan Authority, which provides student loans for higher education;

•The Rhode Island Turnpike and Bridge Authority, which maintains the Pell and Mount Hope Bridges.

Top earners in 2007
From 10 quasi-public state agencies.
1

Mark P. BrewerAirport Corporation, President & CEO

$243,798
2

Peter FrazierAirport Corporation, General Counsel & Interim President

192,536
3

Brian SchattleAirport Corporation, Senior Vice President & CFO

177,200
4

Richard GodfreyR.I. Housing, Executive Director

175,029
5

Paul PinaultNarragansett Bay Commission, Executive Director

165,423
6

Alfred J. MoscolaRIPTA, General Manager

164,886
7

Michael O’ConnellResource Recovery, Executive Director

153,925
8

Raymond MarshallNarragansett Bay Commission, Executive Director

153,093
9

Thomas HoggR.I. Housing, Deputy Director - Finance & CFO

151,639
10

Patricia A. GoldsteinAirport Corporation, Vice President - Public Affairs

141,654

SOURCE: R.I. quasi-public agenciesTHE PROVIDENCE JOURNAL

Top earners at Rhode Island quasi-public agencies in 2007
State law requires public agencies to disclose the base pay, overtime pay and other pay of its employees. The law applies to quasi-public state agencies, 10 of which process their own payrolls and are reflected in this list.
TotalBaseOTOther
1Mark P. Brewer, Airport Corp., President & CEO$243,798$243,798$0$0
2Peter Frazier, Airport Corp., General Counsel & Interim Pres.192,536192,53600
3Brian Schattle, Airport Corp., Sr. Vice Pres. & CFO177,200177,20000
4Richard Godfrey, R.I. Housing, Executive Director175,029161,239013,790
5Paul Pinault, Narr. Bay Commission, Executive Director165,423165,42300
6Alfred J. Moscola, RIPTA, General Manager164,886159,88605,000
7Michael O’Connell, Resource Recovery, Executive Director153,925128,511025,413
8Raymond Marshall, Narr. Bay Commission, Executive Director153,093153,09300
9Thomas Hogg, R.I. Housing, Deputy Director - Finance & CFO151,639141,136010,503
10Patricia A. Goldstein, Airport Corp., Vice Pres. - Public Affairs141,654141,65400
11Brenda L. Pope, Airport Corp., Vice Pres. - Environmental Ssytems141,145141,14500
12Margaret Thurber, R.I. Housing, Mortgage Sales Manager139,52142,000097,521
13James P. McCarvill, Convention Ctr. Auth., Executive Director139,364139,36400
14Paul E. Nordstrom, Narr. Bay Commission, Operations & Engineering Director135,972135,97200
15Susan Bodington, R.I. Housing, Deputy Director - Programs134,737127,31607,421
16Dennis P. Arusso, Resource Recovery, Operations Manager134,69297,564037,128
17Bruce Wilde, Airport Corp., Chief Human Resources Officer134,602134,60200
18Marci Greenberger, Airport Corp., Sr. Vice Pres. Operations & Maintenance133,193133,19300
19Karen L. Giebink, Narr. Bay Commission, Administration & Finance Director132,968132,96800
20John Gordon, R.I. Housing, Director - Asset Management131,251123,83007,421
21Cathleen Paniccia, R.I. Housing, Director - Homeownership127,648120,22707,421
22Ann Palmisciano, R.I. Housing, Mortgage Originator122,65020,0000102,650
23Robert Donovan, Health & Educational Bldg., Executive Director122,308122,30800
24Leslie McKnight, R.I. Housing, Director - Servicing121,043110,793010,250
25Douglas R. Dansereau, Airport Corp., Chief Auditor & Financial Analyst117,308117,30800
26Buddy Croft, Turnpike & Bridge, Executive Director115,489115,48900
27Jose D. DaSilva, Airport Corp., Asst. Vice Pres. - Bldg Maintenance115,482115,48200
28William Parsons, Economic Development, Deputy Director115,051115,05100
29John Scott, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer114,48775,20239,2840
30Claude A. Cote, Resource Recovery, Regulatory Compliance Director114,21794,514019,704
31Carol Ventura, R.I. Housing, Director - Development113,960106,53907,421
32Andre Lefebvre, Resource Recovery, General Plant Manager113,63393,434020,199
33Richard Reed, Economic Development, Deputy Director112,851112,85100
34David J. Wilga, Airport Corp., Chief Technology Officer111,998111,99800
35Richard Bernier, Narr. Bay Commission, Construction Services Director111,353111,35300
36Joseph J. Judge, Resource Recovery, CFO110,678106,98403,694
37David F. Edwards, Airport Corp., Asst. Vice Pres. - Operations & Maintenance110,364110,36400
38Thomas G. Brueckner, Narr. Bay Commission, Engineering Manager110,313110,31300
39James Michael Saul, Economic Development, Managing Director - Finance109,661109,66100
40Mark R. Thomas, Narr. Bay Commission, Asst. Construction Manager109,563109,56300
41Robert A. Emmott, Airport Corp., Fire Captain108,84171,11537,7260
42Craig Force, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer108,68376,08332,5990
43Thomas P. Uva, Narr. Bay Commission, Planning, Policy & Regulation Director107,987107,98700
44Henry S. Kinch, RIPTA, Deputy General Manager107,354101,24606,108
45James B. Gardiner, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer106,92077,14029,7810
46Jason Doyle, Airport Corp., Controller106,069106,06900
47Michael Milito, R.I. Housing, Dep. Asst. Director - Law & Human Resources106,045101,33704,708
48Robert T. Lavallee Jr., Airport Corp., Police Sergeant105,42277,76927,6530
49Joseph C. Ottaviano, Airport Corp., Police Inspector104,63780,17824,4590
50William M. Anderson, Resource Recovery, Engineering Manager104,38584,823019,562
51Laurie H. Bissonette, Narr. Bay Commission, Executive Affairs Director103,979103,97900
52Peter Janaros, Turnpike & Bridge, Engineering Director103,920103,92000
53Stephen F. Catanzaro, Airport Corp., Electrical Supervisor103,83781,49322,3440
54Noel Simpson, Student Loan Auth., CFO103,151103,15100
55David A. Cloutier, Airport Corp., Asst. Vice Pres. - Commercial Programs102,524102,52400
56Steven King, Economic Development, Chief Operating Officer102,216102,21600
57Gerald Brolin Jr., Airport Corp., Environmental Programs Manager101,707101,70700
58Robert A. Perry, Airport Corp., Fire Captain101,59371,11530,4770
59Ahmed D. Shihadeh, Airport Corp., Engineering Manager101,517101,51700
60David M. Olbrych, Airport Corp., Police Lieutenant101,26891,5049,7640
61Amy Rainone, R.I. Housing, Director - Policy101,11693,60007,516
62John E. Thomas, Airport Corp., Chief - ARFF101,009101,00900
63James Warcup, Airport Corp., Aeronautics Inspector100,92193,8077,1140
64John R. Searle, Airport Corp., Captain - ARFF100,91166,59134,3200
65Joseph M. Monti, RIPTA, Asst. Supt. Maintenance100,85766,53331,7722,552
66Saul Kaplan, Economic Development, Executive Director & CEO99,70099,70000
67Robert K. Hastings, Airport Corp., Police Sergeant99,58284,37615,2060
68Brian Card, Resource Recovery, Manager99,50686,798012,708
69Richard G. Snead Jr., Airport Corp., Patrol Officer99,29874,60024,6980
70Deborah A. Dawson, RIPTA, Assistant General Manager99,24399,24300
71Ernest Golding, Airport Corp., Police Lieutenant98,82487,90410,9190
72Luke J. Skunza, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer98,39071,06027,3300
73William A. Blair, RIPTA, Full-time Bus Operator98,34248,01349,0441,285
74Ronald P. Martin, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer98,32774,21324,1140
75Charles E. Hall Jr., Airport Corp., Police Sergeant98,25873,69424,5640
76Bernard E. Klumbis, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer98,11474,35023,7640
77Steven A. Marcaccio, Resource Recovery, Superintendent97,40670,952026,453
78Edward J. Scott, RIPTA, Assistant General Manager97,13991,76805,371
79Robert G. Lafond, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer96,26075,17121,0890
80James F. Dean, RIPTA, Assistant General Manager96,24590,92305,322
81Mark R. Therrien, RIPTA, Assistant General Manager94,97688,21906,756
82Daniel T. Smith, Narr. Bay Commission, Information Technology Manager94,82994,82900
83Susan Monaghan, R.I. Housing, Assistant Director - Assets94,76393,24701,516
84Bernard J. Harwood, RIPTA, Assistant General Manager94,35190,92303,428
85Richard J. Rotondo, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer94,21073,76920,4410
86Carmine J. Goneconte, Narr. Bay Commission, Operations Manager94,02494,02400
87Maureen S. Neira, RIPTA, Assistant General Manager & CFO93,70692,9780728
88Walter R. Salisbury Jr., Airport Corp., Police Lieutenant93,09187,7025,3880
89Steven P. Pietrantozzi, Resource Recovery, Scalehouse Manager93,08448,14232,18412,758
90Dennis J. Ray, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer93,07575,76617,3090
91Katharine Flynn, Economic Development, Director - Business Development92,88192,88100
92Fred Hashway, Economic Development, Intergovernmental Relation Director92,51492,51400
93John F. Braga, RIPTA, Maintenance Director92,28486,86405,420
94Franco Della Posta, Resource Recovery, Asst. Superintendent91,70844,27136,61810,820
95David L. Moran Jr., Airport Corp., Fire Lieutenant & EMT91,59266,08225,5100
96Malcolm E. Emery, Airport Corp., Electrician91,36475,64315,7210
97Michael S. Mini, Airport Corp., Planning Manager91,24691,24600
98Roland H. Fournier, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer91,00076,80614,1940
99Michael P. McGonagle, Resource Recovery, Info. Systems & Analysis Director90,92373,715017,208
100James O. Daley, RIPTA, Assistant General Manager90,56890,56800

SOURCE: 10 Rhode Island quasi-public agencies that process their own payrollsTHE PROVIDENCE JOURNAL

Average earnings at quasi-public agencies
Average earnings for employees at 10 quasi-public state agencies are shown here by calendar year, along with the number of employees who worked at the agency for any period that year and the percentage of total pay represented by overtime. The total pay shown here includes earnings in addition to base pay and overtime.
YearEmployeesTotal payBase payOvertime
Rhode Island Airport Corporation2006201$62,380$55,521$6,85911.0%
200720173,86266,6887,1749.7%
Convention Center Authority2006763,80963,80900%
2007857,91757,91700%
Economic Development200611447,61046,7758351.8%
200710256,62355,7099141.6%
Health & Educational Building2006380,39180,39100%
2007553,07753,07700%
Rhode Island Housing200618348,30644,135630.1%
200720047,80543,204890.2%
Narragansett Bay Commission200626645,09743,4481,6493.7%
200726746,36844,6051,7633.8%
Resource Recovery200613558,54838,48112,88222.0%
200714456,64735,95512,66622.4%
RIPTA200689644,86337,7786,18013.8%
200789546,56939,3896,27113.5%
Student Loan Authority2006461,20861,20800%
20075413,81313,767460.3%
Turnpike & Bridge20065131,18730,5856021.9%
20075332,16931,5616081.9%

SOURCE: Rhode Island quasi-public agenciesTHE PROVIDENCE JOURNAL

pparker@projo.com

Advertisement