Business
Airport salaries soar above most other state agencies
01:00 AM EDT on Sunday, July 20, 2008
The airport is where the money is, at least as far as paychecks at quasi-public state agencies in Rhode Island are concerned.
A Providence Journal review of payroll records from 10 quasi-public state agencies found that employees at the Rhode Island Airport Corporation had the highest average paychecks in 2007, as well as having 4 of the 10 highest paid employees and 42 of the 100 highest paid.
Airport employees also land a fair share of overtime dollars, although those who drive a bus or work at the state’s Central Landfill rake in more.
Generally speaking, quasi-public state agencies are formed by the state but have at least partially separate legal identities, such as the ability to borrow money independently or to be sued separately from the state. The quasi-public agencies often look more like businesses than departments of state government. In Rhode Island, they do things such as run airports, operate transit buses and help first-time house buyers get mortgages.
Under state law, employees of the quasi-public agencies are public employees, and certain information from their personnel files is part of the public record. That includes their names, job titles and earnings information.
The Journal’s examination of the payrolls of quasi-public agencies follows earlier looks at state, municipal and public school employees. Some quasi-public agencies — including the state colleges and the public television station — process their payrolls through the state Department of Administration. The 10 agencies that are the subject of today’s review handle their own payrolls.
The highest paid at those 10 agencies last year was Mark P. Brewer, president and chief executive officer of the airport corporation. His $243,798 paycheck made him one of the highest paid of all state employees.
To make a direct comparison, the Journal also looked at 2006 earnings, because those were available for all state, municipal and school employees, as well as workers at the quasi-public agencies.
In that year, Brewer was paid $254,318. That trailed only James E. Baron, the men’s basketball coach at URI, who grossed $301,324. The highest paid public school employee that year was Donnie W. Evans, the former Providence schools superintendent, who grossed $190,742. Among municipal employees, the top earner was Michael J. Day, deputy assistant fire chief in Providence, although a substantial portion of his $186,541 in earnings was severance pay after he died on the job.
In 2007, the airport claimed the top three spots among employees of quasi-public agencies.
After Brewer, second-place went to Peter Frazier, the corporation’s lawyer. Frazier, whose pay totaled $192,536, also filled in as president after Brewer left to head the Manchester-Boston Regional Airport in New Hampshire. As a result, Brewer did not collect a full year’s salary.
Third was Brian Schattle, senior vice president and chief financial officer, who grossed $177,200.
A fourth airport employee, spokeswoman Patricia A. Goldstein, was the 10th-highest paid, grossing $141,654.
“The salaries may seem high, but that’s the reality of recruiting in the aviation field,” said Kevin A. Dillon, current airport corporation president. “You necessarily have to go and try to recruit folks away from other airports.”
He said a study completed last month showed Rhode Island airport salaries to be within the range of similar airports.
The biggest user of overtime last year, in terms of the percentage of total payroll, was the Rhode Island Resource Recovery Corporation, which runs the state’s dump. The corporation averaged overtime that was 22 percent of each worker’s total pay last year.
That use of overtime was a strategic decision, according to Michael O’Connell, the agency’s executive director.
The state requires the dump to operate 10 1/2 hours a day on weekdays, plus 6 1/2 hours on Saturdays. Instead of creating 40-hour-a-week schedules that cover all those hours, the corporation just has employees put in overtime.
“Rather than hire a bunch of extra people and pay them a benefit package, which you never recover, it makes more sense to pay overtime,” said O’Connell. “Economically, it always pays to run overtime than to hire more people.”
But, he said, the use of overtime is a high-wire act.
“Zero overtime — zero means you have too many people,” O’Connell said. “Too much and you’re wearing them out.”
Although Resource Recovery doles out the most overtime as a percentage of payroll, the biggest bucks come from the Rhode Island Public Transit Authority, which employs the overtime king.
Last year, RIPTA paid more than $5.6 million in overtime, with most of that going to the people who drive transit buses and the vans that transport people with disabilities.
More than half that overtime was planned, accord to Mark R. Therrien, a RIPTA assistant general manager. “In our industry, scheduled overtime is a strategic call,” he said. Part of that strategy is scheduling for a work day that has to be longer than eight hours to accommodate the schedules of RIPTA’s biggest customers, commuters who get rides before and after their own eight-hour work days.
Tops last year among all overtime earners at the quasi-public agencies was bus driver William A. Blair, who added $49,044 in overtime to his base pay of $48,013. With other earnings, his pay for the year totaled $98,342.
“Bill Blair never leaves the place practically,” said Therrien. “He’s the most senior driver at RIPTA, and he works any overtime he can.” Schedules and overtime are driven by seniority, and, Therrien said, Blair arranges his regular work schedule to be available at the times that have the most unplanned overtime, usually the result of someone calling in sick.
The airport was the third-biggest user of overtime, with about 10 percent of its payroll going to overtime payments.
“It’s something that any manager wants to shrink down as much as possible,” said airport president Dillon.
He said three factors beyond his control cause overtime situations.
One is snow removal. “We don’t have the option of saying we’re just going to close down” and wait out a storm, he said.
Another is maintaining adequate numbers of security personnel at times they weren’t expected to be needed. “When you have delayed flights, I have to hold people over,” he said.
The third is the airport fire department. Airport certification requires staffing levels to be maintained, even when workers call in sick or are absent for other reasons.
Besides resembling businesses in what they do, the quasi-public agencies were similar in how employees are paid.
In many state agencies, the top earner is a long-time rank-and-file employee, who has a high base salary because of longevity and high overtime earnings because seniority is often a factor in selecting employees for extra shifts.
But at 8 of the 10 quasi-publics looked at by The Journal, the head of the agency was the top earner. At the other two, the top earner was a high-ranking deputy.
Besides the Airport Corporation, Resource Recovery and RIPTA, the other quasi-publics looked at by The Journal were:
•The Rhode Island Convention Center Authority, which runs the convention center and civic center arena in Providence;
•The Rhode Island Economic Development Corporation, which helps attract businesses and keep them here;
•The Rhode Island Health and Educational Building Corporation, which helps schools, hospitals and similar agencies secure financing for building projects;
•Rhode Island Housing, the mortgage and housing agency;
•The Narragansett Bay Commission, which runs the sewer systems and treatment facilities that serve all or part of 10 communities in the Providence area;
•The Rhode Island Student Loan Authority, which provides student loans for higher education;
•The Rhode Island Turnpike and Bridge Authority, which maintains the Pell and Mount Hope Bridges. Mark P. BrewerAirport Corporation, President & CEO Peter FrazierAirport Corporation, General Counsel & Interim President Brian SchattleAirport Corporation, Senior Vice President & CFO Richard GodfreyR.I. Housing, Executive Director Paul PinaultNarragansett Bay Commission, Executive Director Alfred J. MoscolaRIPTA, General Manager Michael O’ConnellResource Recovery, Executive Director Raymond MarshallNarragansett Bay Commission, Executive Director Thomas HoggR.I. Housing, Deputy Director - Finance & CFO Patricia A. GoldsteinAirport Corporation, Vice President - Public Affairs SOURCE: R.I. quasi-public agenciesTHE PROVIDENCE JOURNAL SOURCE: 10 Rhode Island quasi-public agencies that process their own payrollsTHE PROVIDENCE JOURNAL SOURCE: Rhode Island quasi-public agenciesTHE PROVIDENCE JOURNALTop earners in 2007 From 10 quasi-public state agencies. 1 $243,798 2 192,536 3 177,200 4 175,029 5 165,423 6 164,886 7 153,925 8 153,093 9 151,639 10 141,654 Top earners at Rhode Island quasi-public agencies in 2007 State law requires public agencies to disclose the base pay, overtime pay and other pay of its employees. The law applies to quasi-public state agencies, 10 of which process their own payrolls and are reflected in this list. Total Base OT Other 1 Mark P. Brewer, Airport Corp., President & CEO $243,798 $243,798 $0 $0 2 Peter Frazier, Airport Corp., General Counsel & Interim Pres. 192,536 192,536 0 0 3 Brian Schattle, Airport Corp., Sr. Vice Pres. & CFO 177,200 177,200 0 0 4 Richard Godfrey, R.I. Housing, Executive Director 175,029 161,239 0 13,790 5 Paul Pinault, Narr. Bay Commission, Executive Director 165,423 165,423 0 0 6 Alfred J. Moscola, RIPTA, General Manager 164,886 159,886 0 5,000 7 Michael O’Connell, Resource Recovery, Executive Director 153,925 128,511 0 25,413 8 Raymond Marshall, Narr. Bay Commission, Executive Director 153,093 153,093 0 0 9 Thomas Hogg, R.I. Housing, Deputy Director - Finance & CFO 151,639 141,136 0 10,503 10 Patricia A. Goldstein, Airport Corp., Vice Pres. - Public Affairs 141,654 141,654 0 0 11 Brenda L. Pope, Airport Corp., Vice Pres. - Environmental Ssytems 141,145 141,145 0 0 12 Margaret Thurber, R.I. Housing, Mortgage Sales Manager 139,521 42,000 0 97,521 13 James P. McCarvill, Convention Ctr. Auth., Executive Director 139,364 139,364 0 0 14 Paul E. Nordstrom, Narr. Bay Commission, Operations & Engineering Director 135,972 135,972 0 0 15 Susan Bodington, R.I. Housing, Deputy Director - Programs 134,737 127,316 0 7,421 16 Dennis P. Arusso, Resource Recovery, Operations Manager 134,692 97,564 0 37,128 17 Bruce Wilde, Airport Corp., Chief Human Resources Officer 134,602 134,602 0 0 18 Marci Greenberger, Airport Corp., Sr. Vice Pres. Operations & Maintenance 133,193 133,193 0 0 19 Karen L. Giebink, Narr. Bay Commission, Administration & Finance Director 132,968 132,968 0 0 20 John Gordon, R.I. Housing, Director - Asset Management 131,251 123,830 0 7,421 21 Cathleen Paniccia, R.I. Housing, Director - Homeownership 127,648 120,227 0 7,421 22 Ann Palmisciano, R.I. Housing, Mortgage Originator 122,650 20,000 0 102,650 23 Robert Donovan, Health & Educational Bldg., Executive Director 122,308 122,308 0 0 24 Leslie McKnight, R.I. Housing, Director - Servicing 121,043 110,793 0 10,250 25 Douglas R. Dansereau, Airport Corp., Chief Auditor & Financial Analyst 117,308 117,308 0 0 26 Buddy Croft, Turnpike & Bridge, Executive Director 115,489 115,489 0 0 27 Jose D. DaSilva, Airport Corp., Asst. Vice Pres. - Bldg Maintenance 115,482 115,482 0 0 28 William Parsons, Economic Development, Deputy Director 115,051 115,051 0 0 29 John Scott, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer 114,487 75,202 39,284 0 30 Claude A. Cote, Resource Recovery, Regulatory Compliance Director 114,217 94,514 0 19,704 31 Carol Ventura, R.I. Housing, Director - Development 113,960 106,539 0 7,421 32 Andre Lefebvre, Resource Recovery, General Plant Manager 113,633 93,434 0 20,199 33 Richard Reed, Economic Development, Deputy Director 112,851 112,851 0 0 34 David J. Wilga, Airport Corp., Chief Technology Officer 111,998 111,998 0 0 35 Richard Bernier, Narr. Bay Commission, Construction Services Director 111,353 111,353 0 0 36 Joseph J. Judge, Resource Recovery, CFO 110,678 106,984 0 3,694 37 David F. Edwards, Airport Corp., Asst. Vice Pres. - Operations & Maintenance 110,364 110,364 0 0 38 Thomas G. Brueckner, Narr. Bay Commission, Engineering Manager 110,313 110,313 0 0 39 James Michael Saul, Economic Development, Managing Director - Finance 109,661 109,661 0 0 40 Mark R. Thomas, Narr. Bay Commission, Asst. Construction Manager 109,563 109,563 0 0 41 Robert A. Emmott, Airport Corp., Fire Captain 108,841 71,115 37,726 0 42 Craig Force, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer 108,683 76,083 32,599 0 43 Thomas P. Uva, Narr. Bay Commission, Planning, Policy & Regulation Director 107,987 107,987 0 0 44 Henry S. Kinch, RIPTA, Deputy General Manager 107,354 101,246 0 6,108 45 James B. Gardiner, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer 106,920 77,140 29,781 0 46 Jason Doyle, Airport Corp., Controller 106,069 106,069 0 0 47 Michael Milito, R.I. Housing, Dep. Asst. Director - Law & Human Resources 106,045 101,337 0 4,708 48 Robert T. Lavallee Jr., Airport Corp., Police Sergeant 105,422 77,769 27,653 0 49 Joseph C. Ottaviano, Airport Corp., Police Inspector 104,637 80,178 24,459 0 50 William M. Anderson, Resource Recovery, Engineering Manager 104,385 84,823 0 19,562 51 Laurie H. Bissonette, Narr. Bay Commission, Executive Affairs Director 103,979 103,979 0 0 52 Peter Janaros, Turnpike & Bridge, Engineering Director 103,920 103,920 0 0 53 Stephen F. Catanzaro, Airport Corp., Electrical Supervisor 103,837 81,493 22,344 0 54 Noel Simpson, Student Loan Auth., CFO 103,151 103,151 0 0 55 David A. Cloutier, Airport Corp., Asst. Vice Pres. - Commercial Programs 102,524 102,524 0 0 56 Steven King, Economic Development, Chief Operating Officer 102,216 102,216 0 0 57 Gerald Brolin Jr., Airport Corp., Environmental Programs Manager 101,707 101,707 0 0 58 Robert A. Perry, Airport Corp., Fire Captain 101,593 71,115 30,477 0 59 Ahmed D. Shihadeh, Airport Corp., Engineering Manager 101,517 101,517 0 0 60 David M. Olbrych, Airport Corp., Police Lieutenant 101,268 91,504 9,764 0 61 Amy Rainone, R.I. Housing, Director - Policy 101,116 93,600 0 7,516 62 John E. Thomas, Airport Corp., Chief - ARFF 101,009 101,009 0 0 63 James Warcup, Airport Corp., Aeronautics Inspector 100,921 93,807 7,114 0 64 John R. Searle, Airport Corp., Captain - ARFF 100,911 66,591 34,320 0 65 Joseph M. Monti, RIPTA, Asst. Supt. Maintenance 100,857 66,533 31,772 2,552 66 Saul Kaplan, Economic Development, Executive Director & CEO 99,700 99,700 0 0 67 Robert K. Hastings, Airport Corp., Police Sergeant 99,582 84,376 15,206 0 68 Brian Card, Resource Recovery, Manager 99,506 86,798 0 12,708 69 Richard G. Snead Jr., Airport Corp., Patrol Officer 99,298 74,600 24,698 0 70 Deborah A. Dawson, RIPTA, Assistant General Manager 99,243 99,243 0 0 71 Ernest Golding, Airport Corp., Police Lieutenant 98,824 87,904 10,919 0 72 Luke J. Skunza, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer 98,390 71,060 27,330 0 73 William A. Blair, RIPTA, Full-time Bus Operator 98,342 48,013 49,044 1,285 74 Ronald P. Martin, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer 98,327 74,213 24,114 0 75 Charles E. Hall Jr., Airport Corp., Police Sergeant 98,258 73,694 24,564 0 76 Bernard E. Klumbis, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer 98,114 74,350 23,764 0 77 Steven A. Marcaccio, Resource Recovery, Superintendent 97,406 70,952 0 26,453 78 Edward J. Scott, RIPTA, Assistant General Manager 97,139 91,768 0 5,371 79 Robert G. Lafond, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer 96,260 75,171 21,089 0 80 James F. Dean, RIPTA, Assistant General Manager 96,245 90,923 0 5,322 81 Mark R. Therrien, RIPTA, Assistant General Manager 94,976 88,219 0 6,756 82 Daniel T. Smith, Narr. Bay Commission, Information Technology Manager 94,829 94,829 0 0 83 Susan Monaghan, R.I. Housing, Assistant Director - Assets 94,763 93,247 0 1,516 84 Bernard J. Harwood, RIPTA, Assistant General Manager 94,351 90,923 0 3,428 85 Richard J. Rotondo, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer 94,210 73,769 20,441 0 86 Carmine J. Goneconte, Narr. Bay Commission, Operations Manager 94,024 94,024 0 0 87 Maureen S. Neira, RIPTA, Assistant General Manager & CFO 93,706 92,978 0 728 88 Walter R. Salisbury Jr., Airport Corp., Police Lieutenant 93,091 87,702 5,388 0 89 Steven P. Pietrantozzi, Resource Recovery, Scalehouse Manager 93,084 48,142 32,184 12,758 90 Dennis J. Ray, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer 93,075 75,766 17,309 0 91 Katharine Flynn, Economic Development, Director - Business Development 92,881 92,881 0 0 92 Fred Hashway, Economic Development, Intergovernmental Relation Director 92,514 92,514 0 0 93 John F. Braga, RIPTA, Maintenance Director 92,284 86,864 0 5,420 94 Franco Della Posta, Resource Recovery, Asst. Superintendent 91,708 44,271 36,618 10,820 95 David L. Moran Jr., Airport Corp., Fire Lieutenant & EMT 91,592 66,082 25,510 0 96 Malcolm E. Emery, Airport Corp., Electrician 91,364 75,643 15,721 0 97 Michael S. Mini, Airport Corp., Planning Manager 91,246 91,246 0 0 98 Roland H. Fournier, Airport Corp., Patrol Officer 91,000 76,806 14,194 0 99 Michael P. McGonagle, Resource Recovery, Info. Systems & Analysis Director 90,923 73,715 0 17,208 100 James O. Daley, RIPTA, Assistant General Manager 90,568 90,568 0 0 Average earnings at quasi-public agencies Average earnings for employees at 10 quasi-public state agencies are shown here by calendar year, along with the number of employees who worked at the agency for any period that year and the percentage of total pay represented by overtime. The total pay shown here includes earnings in addition to base pay and overtime. Year Employees Total pay Base pay Overtime Rhode Island Airport Corporation 2006 201 $62,380 $55,521 $6,859 11.0% 2007 201 73,862 66,688 7,174 9.7% Convention Center Authority 2006 7 63,809 63,809 0 0% 2007 8 57,917 57,917 0 0% Economic Development 2006 114 47,610 46,775 835 1.8% 2007 102 56,623 55,709 914 1.6% Health & Educational Building 2006 3 80,391 80,391 0 0% 2007 5 53,077 53,077 0 0% Rhode Island Housing 2006 183 48,306 44,135 63 0.1% 2007 200 47,805 43,204 89 0.2% Narragansett Bay Commission 2006 266 45,097 43,448 1,649 3.7% 2007 267 46,368 44,605 1,763 3.8% Resource Recovery 2006 135 58,548 38,481 12,882 22.0% 2007 144 56,647 35,955 12,666 22.4% RIPTA 2006 896 44,863 37,778 6,180 13.8% 2007 895 46,569 39,389 6,271 13.5% Student Loan Authority 2006 4 61,208 61,208 0 0% 2007 54 13,813 13,767 46 0.3% Turnpike & Bridge 2006 51 31,187 30,585 602 1.9% 2007 53 32,169 31,561 608 1.9%
|
More business stories
Most viewed yesterday
Donaldson -- Brady's health will determine how far these Patriots go
After two preseason games, Patriots are far from being a super team
Inmate had sex with supervisor during work release, officials say
West Warwick, state of Rhode Island propose settlements in Station fire
Most active surveys
Are you considering switching to a cheaper alternative to heat your home?
Should the drinking age be lowered?
React to the latest Station fire settlement offer
Most e-mailed in the last 24 hours









